Translate

Guide to Patagonia's Monsters & Mysterious beings

I have written a book on this intriguing subject which has just been published.
In this blog I will post excerpts and other interesting texts on this fascinating subject.

Austin Whittall


Showing posts with label redheaded. Show all posts
Showing posts with label redheaded. Show all posts

Sunday, October 18, 2026

Bulrush based societies have existed for over 30 kya


In my recent series of posts about the redheaded "giants" of Lovelock Cave, Nevada, I mentioned that they had developed a lifestyle adapted to living by and on the lakes (dwindling after the Last Ice Age) of the Great Basin Region. They thrived on bulrushes. The Paiute people, who exterminated the last bands of these people called them Si-te-cah or tule-eaters, after the bulrushes known as tule, that they exploited in their lacustrine and fluvial territory.


Early humans, who lived a hunter-gatherer life, included bulrushes as part of their diet. They ate the tender shoots, and cooked, baked, and ground the roots or rhizomes of these plants into flour. They also used the stems to make mats, baskets, huts, and boats. The Si-te-cah people lived on floating rush islands, in a similar way to the Uro people of Lake Titicaca in Peru and Bolivia.


bulrush global distribution
Fig 1. Global distribution of Typha species (bulrushes). Source

The map above shows the global distribution of the cattail family, the Typhaceae. They are found in wetlands across the world, from New Zealand to Canada. Their name Typha comes from the Greek word for marsh. They can survive in wet, hot, cold, and continental climates, even in freezing icy conditions.


An ancient lifestyle


The oldest proof of bulrush exploitation has been found at Upper Paleolithic sites in Europe, dating back 30,000 years (30 ky).


In a research paper, Revedin et al., 2010, (Thirty thousand-year-old evidence of plant food processing, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 107 (44) 18815-18819, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1006993107) discuss the discovery of grinding implements used at European sites:


Bilancino II (Italy), Kostenki 16–Uglyanka (Russia), and Pavlov VI (Czech Republic). They ground different kinds of plants, and these have been identified: Bilancino II is 28 ky old, and the "highly specialized tool types were probably used for the separation of the vegetable fibers from cattail (Typha) leaves... Considering the size distribution of the morphotype e grains, the mode of the measured values is closer to that calculated for Typha angustifolia (narrow leaf cattail) than to that of Typha latifolia (broadleaf cattail) ."


Kostenki site is roughly 31 ky old, moonworts were processed with stone mortars. At Pavlov VI (29 ky old), moonworts and cattails were pounded into flour.


The authors point out that "the practices that we can reconstruct demonstrate knowledge in the Gravettian populations of Europe of the starch-rich portions of edible plants, combined with the ability to transform them to produce a complex dried product (flour). This would have allowed them greater independence from environmental and seasonal fluctuations." Did other hominins adopt this lifestyle?


Neanderthals and rushes


A paper (Hardy BL, Moncel MH. Neanderthal use of fish, mammals, birds, starchy plants and wood 125-250,000 years ago. PLoS One. 2011;6(8):e23768. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0023768. Epub 2011 Aug 24. PMID: 21887315; PMCID: PMC3161061.) reported that Neanderthals living in the Rhone Valley in France 250,000 to 125,000 years ago, processed the starchy roots of plants using stone tools. Were they bulrushes? We don't know for certain. But this site, at Payre shows they were well equipped to obtain starchy carbohydrates from local plants.


China 10,000 years BP


More recently, rushes were used as food in China as reported by Zhang et al., 2020 (Typha as a wetland food resource: evidence from the Tianluoshan site, Lower Yangtze Region, China some 10,000 years ago). The article discusses the people who inhabited the wetlands along the Yangtze River in China. They found "extremely high percentages of Typha" (bulrush) pollen in their fossilized feces. This site is more recent than those discussed in the previous section, and belong to Neolithic humans. This is close to the birth of agriculture ~10 kya, and these people were also exploiting rice. They note that "The coexistence of Typha and rice also gives clues about the environmental background and agricultural management of early rice paddy, with respect to eutrophication, weeding and inundation." Hinting at agricultural practices regarding the bulrushes.


Australian Aboriginals (past 60 ky)


Ken Macintyre and Barb Dobson, 2023 report that the original people of Australia added Typha rhizomes to their diet. They processed these roots into edible flour, and baked bread from it. They also managed the bulrush growth by burning the dry stands during the dry season. This "muck" burning returned nutrients to the soil and promoted the growth of larger rhizomes which had fewer "hairs" and were thicker.


This was a very ancient practice, and Macintyre & Dobson suggest that "We would assume given the antiquity of Australian Aboriginal culture that if such archaeological research were to be systematically conducted on grinding materials from southwestern Australia that the results could well predate these European findings", in other words, they would be older than the 30,000 years reported by Revedin et al.


North American Natives


In my Lovelock series I mentioned the Umatilla people as also being named "tule-eaters" by the Paiute. They lived in Oregon, and although they were not lacustrine like the Tulares or the Lake Tule (Modocs), they also exploited the tule bulrushes. The picture below, by Lee Moorhouse (1850-1926) is captioned "Indian camps on Columbia river, opposite Umatilla c.1900-1910 and depicts "a tipi made of boards, poles, mats and cloth is located on the flat, rocky shore of the Columbia River. Nearby are two horses." The tipi is made of bulrush reed mats. They were light, strong, and provided insulation. They swelled up when wet, provided a waterproof roof.


Umatilla Tipi

Below is Lake Tule, where the Modocs lived (Source), by the way, the scenery is magnificent.


Lake Tule California

Many natives lived in reed huts and we have a drawing by F. Wikersheim described as Californie, rancheria des Indiens d' hocks sur les bords de la rivière de la plume. (cluster of huts of the Hocks Indians. California, on the banks of Feather River, near Yuba city, drawn c.1850 during the California Gold Rush.


rancheria Feather River 1850s

In this same area (close to Yuba City), we have another drawing of a native encampment (Robert B. Honeyman, Jr. Collection, c.1850s). Both images correspond to the Sacramento River valley.


Yuba city rancheria

The Yokut people of Lake Tulare and the San Joaquin River basin also built tule huts. The following image, from Contributions to North American ethnology. Vol. III, by John W. Powell, 1873, p. 231 shows "Yo'-kuts Tule Lodges":


Yokuts tule lodges, 1873

Powell describes their lifestyle: "In the mountain streams which empty into Tulare Lake they catch lake trout, chubs, and suckers... On Tulare Lake they construct very rude, frail punts or mere troughs of tule, about ten feet long, in which they cruise timidly about near the shore... Their range of food is extensive. Around the lake they cut and dry the seed-stalks of a kind of flag (Typha) which has a head something like a teasel, thresh out the seed and make flour of if; also wild rye and wild sunflower seed...."


The Paiute once again try to exterminate the tule-eaters


Interestingly, Powell also records that the Yokuts were under attack by "the more powerful and warlike Paiuti of Nevada" who managed to bypass the Sierra Nevada through the "the passes which occur at the northern and southern points of junction between the Sierra and the Coast Range... allowed ... the Paiuti... to swarm in toward the rich and tempting plains of California, dispossessing the feebler peoples who were there before them. Living as they do at the lower end of the great basin, the Yokuts received the brunt of the Paiuti attacks. So severe were the latter that the Yokuts, as a geographically solid body of allied tribes, were cut in two in one place and nearly in another. Their habitat stretched originally from the Fresno River to Fort Tejon; but the Paiuti tribes, swarming through Ta-hi’-cha-pa, Tejon, and Walker's Passes, seized and occupied Kern River, White River, Posa Creek, and Kern Lake, thus completely severing the Yokuts nation, and leaving an isolated fragment of it at Fort Tejon, in a nook of the mountains. Doubtless they would eventually have seized all the streams emptying into Tulare Lake, but they seem to have become enervated by the malaria, and reduced to the same condition of sluggishness as the people whom they displaced." Once again, as with the redheaded giants, the Paiute were aggressive and fought against the peaceful tule-eaters of California.


Ancient links between humans and wetlands


The oldest human footprints in America were discovered in White Sands, New Mexico. Now a barren gypsum dune field, 24,000 years ago it was a freshwater lake (Lake Otero) that covered an area of 4,150 km2 (1,600 sq. mi.). This was a suitable habitat. Wetlands provide fish, water fowl, and attract large animals (drink, and vegetation for foraging). Maybe these very ancient paleoindians also used the tule rushes of the lake (the basin is now known as Tularosa (from "tule" and "rosa" = "pink" in Spanish).


Comments


Rushes are a valuable resource, providing fiber for thatching, mats, footwear, canoes, huts, and baskets. Tender shoots, starchy roots, and the food-rich wetland enviornment surely attracted archaic hominins to this kind of habitat.


In an era that preceded agriculture, controlled burns and a stable settlement by a wetland ensured a year-round food supply. It is very likely that hominins exploited these resources in Eurasia, and after entering America did so in North America. The map at the beginning of this post shows that bulrushes were widely distributed across all of Europe, parts of cental Asia, Japan, Korea, Australia, New Zealand and most of North America. Did hominins that exploited this environment move along this corridor? In Africa, it is mostly absent, and also in southern and souteastern Asia, as well as South and Central America. Were Neanderhtals and Denisovans adapted to using this type of resource?



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Friday, October 16, 2026

Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)


This is the final post of the Lovelock Cave redheaded "giants" (Sixth in the Series). In my previous posts I have discussed the information gathered by the first Western person to visit the cave, John T. Reid.


This is the full series of posts on Lovelock Cave's "giants":

  • Post 1
  • Post 2
  • Post 3
  • Post 4
  • Post 5
  • Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)
  • January 2014 post mentioning Lovelock Cave.


Reid obtained this information from the local Paiute natives, who told him about their oral history and myths. These accounts tell us about a group of tall, redheaded people who were tule-eaters (tule is a variety of bulrush). They were the original people in this area, having arrived before the Paiute. They were well adapted to a lacustrine and fluvial environment, that had gradually been vanishing since the end of the Last Ice Age.


Reid called them Si-te-cah (redheaded tule-eaters). They vanished without a trace because the Paiute exterminated them during a war that lasted several years, and ended at Lovelock Cave. Some versions sayt that a few of these readheaded people managed to get away, making it to Lake Tule and Pit River in Northeastern California.


Summary of the Facts


  • Reid's main informants were Sarah Winnemucca and her nephew Gilbert Natchez (he was the grandson of the Paiute Chief Winnemucca, who was Sarah's father; and the son of Sarah's brother, Natchez Winnemucca). Other natives, and locals also mentioned the readheaded people:
    Sarah: they were "barbarians", people who ate the dead, cannibals, "people eaters". She added that they had "reddish hair" and that she owned a dress made with it.
    Mr. Mah-Wee said the dress existed, and had reddish-brown hair, obtained from the Si-te-cah (tule-eaters).
    Gilbert: They came from the Southwest, were "redheaded" and "very tall" they had spears but not arrows, and dogs with peaky, upright ears. They were also identfied with the "Umatilla's" or Pitt River or Modoc Indians (whe were lacustrine people).
    Taylor says they were the original inhabitants of this area when the Paiute arrived (c. 1000 AD according to Sutton). The Paiute would replace them.
    Bow-E-An (aka "Skinny Dave"): He was the grandson of Natchez and great-nephew of Winnemucca , narrated how his father, Pas-sa Dave (aka "Captain Dave") said they had reddish brown hair and some of them "were very tall". He also called them "Si-te-cah which means 'Tule Eaters'."
  • Lowe and Harrington who excavated Lovelock cave in 1912 and 1924, respectively, added more information: the Paiute called the "ancient people the name sai-duka’a, “tule-eaters,” a name which might be applied to any people with this habit. This may account for the application of the name or its shortened form sai’i to the Pit River Indians and the form Saidyuka [sic] to Indians of eastern Oregon".
  • Comment. In the different soucrces there are several references associating these redheaded giants with the Pit River and Lake Tule (Modoc) people. They lived in NE California and across the border, in southeastern Oregon. They were well adapted to their lakes and rivers habitat. Perhaps this similarity with the lifestyle of the Si-te-cah people led to this connection between both ethnic groups, redheads and Modocs. I will mention this in detail further down.
  • Reid believed they were Neanderthals. A newspaper article about Reid said he called them "red-heads, known scientifically as the Sid-ucah [sic] or Neanderthal race."
    While the local Paiute had "round" skulls, that is, brachycephalic, the redheaded tule-eaters had elongated crania, that is, dolichocephalic. In this, they resemble the Paleoindians (Lagoa Santa, Kennewick Man), and also Neanderthals and Denisovans were long-skulled humans.
  • Natchez added that there was a child-eating "large beast" that lived in the area in the past, called "Ooh-queetz". Reid mentioned a similar creature, a "cave man" called "Pi-Ee-tsah."
  • There were other "Tule eating" natives in California besides the Modocs at Lake Tule, and Pit River; these were the Yokut speakers from Lake Tulare near Fresno and Tulare, CA. The latter believed in a "Hairy Man", a wild-man, similar to bigfoot. They called it "Mayak datat" or "Sunsunut". One of the articles I quoted suggests it was a bigfoot.

Discussion


The now desertic and arid environment at Lovelock, Nevada is very different to the humid conditions that prevailed there when vast lakes covered the Great Basin Region in Nevada and Utah before the end of the last Ice Age. There were people who lived in that lacustrine habitat, thriving on the fish, game and plants that grew in the wetlands surrounding the lakes.


These were the first people in the area, and they were very different from the later arrivals like the Paiute or Shosone.


Baker et al., 2000 using the basket-making techiques of these people was unique, and "has no ethnographic correlates anywhere in North America. The appearance and disappearance of this textile from the Western Great Basin demonstrates a rare technological turnover within a regional basketry sequence characteristic of population replacement" (highlight is mine). The Numic speaking Paiute used "totally different [methods]" to make their baskets.


The replacement of the original population took place ~1000 AD. Baker et al., clearly state that this replacaement ".., means that there was a non-Numic population living in the area before the ancestors of the Northern Paiute arrived."


Who were these people? They were definitely Paleo-Indians, or probably an earlier population, with elongated heads. Their perfect adaptation to the lakes suggests that they had evolved over millennia in contact with this environment. An environment that has a long history in the Great Basin Region and Califnornia.


Lake Tulare in South Central California and its predecessor, Lake Corcoran span a period starting over 750,000 years ago. The Great Basin Lakes formed time and time again over the past 2 million years.


Reid's belief that these people were Neanderthal, due to their skull shape, is probably valid. But, I would suggest that they were Denisovans. These have dolichocephalic skulls like Neanderthals and the readheaded giants, but, unlike the Neanderthals, Denisovans were were big (See my post Denisovans were very tall people!).


I am not convinced about the bigfoot theory, it is likely that the natives had wild-men myths. In fact it is a shared heritage common to most human groups. Wild men, ogres, trolls, hairy giants are found across the world. It could be feasible that the later arrivals, Homo sapiens assigned a primitive child-eating, child-kidnapping behavior to other hominins (wild-men) that arrived earlier to America (Denisovans, Neanderthals, Homo erectus). This would explain the tule eaters description as barbarians and cannibals given by Sarah Winnemucca.


A very wild and farfetched idea is that the redhaired people were of a more primitive kind, for instance gigantopithecus, a giant-sized relative of the orangutans (who have red or orange fur, though we don't know what was the color of gigantopithecus fur). They may have been able to make tools, but it is an implausible possibility.


Red Hair is a unique trait


Readheaded people are not at all common, only 2 to 3% of the total human population have red hair (Source). Red hair or brown hair is extremely rare among Native Americans, who tend to have jet black hair.


The official explanation for the red hair of the Lovelock remains is that chemicals and microbes decolored the hair of the mummified bodies, or that ochre was applied to the hair, coloring it red. Both are valid explanations.


In my 2014 post about Lovelock and the nearby Spirit Cave remains (which also have red hair), I wrote that "Red hair is not at all common among Amerindians or East Asians but Neanderthal had the MC1R gene (melanocortin 1 receptor) associated with red hair in humans... So maybe a band of relict Neanderthals lived in Nevada until quite recently and were wiped out by the Paiute." I made this remark based on a paper by Lalueza-Fox, C., Römpler, H., Hofreiter M., et al., (2007). A melanocortin 1 receptor allele suggests varying pigmentation among Neanderthals. Science, October 25, 2007.


The authors found a mutation in two Neanderthal specimens, a variant that has not yet been detected in humans, the "R307G substitution" in the MC1R (melanocortin 1 receptor) protein that regulates skin and hair color. This substitution causes a partial "loss of function" in the protein, and in human MC1R, a similar loss of function causes pale white skin and red hair. The paper notes that the "Neanderthal individuals that may have had reduced pigmentation levels, possibly even similar to the pale skin color and/or red hair observed in modern humans" and speculates if it could have been the result of selection allowing a better absorption of sunlight in northern Eurasia for vitamin D production in the skin.


As this mutation is different to the one found in humans the paper rules out gene flow and suggest that human and Neanderthals developed red hair through a "convergent evolution of reduced-function MC1R alleles." They note that at least 1% of Nenderthals carried this mutation.


Since 2007, analysis of other Neanderthal specimens has failed to detect this R307G substitution. It must be very rare. These other Neanderthals carry another variant that they passed on to modern humans (see Ding et al., 2014). It is the "Val92Met variant, a loss-of-function variant in MC1R that is associated with multiple dermatological traits including skin color and photoaging. Frequency of this Neanderthal introgression is low in Europeans (∼5%), moderate in continental East Asians (∼30%), and high in Taiwanese aborigines (60–70%)." It causes freckles in Japanese people! Could it cause red hair in Neanderthals?


The modern human mutation causing reduced function on MC1R is ancient. Harding et al., 2000 noted that "for the European red hair–associated Arg151Cys and Arg160Trp variants, we estimate an age of ∼80,000 years." This is far older than modern human remains in Europe. Furthermore, the authors calculated that "the MC1R variants Val60Leu, Val92Met, and Arg163Gln may trace back to ancestors in Eurasian populations existing 250,000–100,000 years ago." Now this date predates the Out of Africa (OOA) event, meaning that these people would have lived in Africa (but there are no redheaded people there). This is inconsistent with the OOA migration. Harding et al., aware of this discrepancy: "... an incompatibility arises between estimated ages in the range of 250,000–100,000 years, for non-African MC1R allelic variation, and ages, from fossil evidence, of ⪱100,000 years for the dispersal of modern humans outside Africa and the Middle East." (They try to explain it away to adapt the dates to the OOA theory).


The point is that red hair is an ancient trait shared by Humans and Neanderthals. Do we know if Denisovans carry this trait? No, we don't. It seems that they don't have the MC1R variants.


But, Tenesa et al., 2018 pointed out that "MC1R only explains 73% of the SNP heritability for red hair in UK Biobank, and in fact most individuals with two MC1R variants have blonde or light brown hair. We identify other genes contributing to red hair, the combined effect of which accounts for ~90% of the SNP heritability" So there are other genes that can cause red hair.


And even in the MC1R there are more variants that can produce redheaded people. A recent paper by Kashyap et al., 2026 searched for mutations in the MC1R gene in 11,000 Indians and found 9 new variants and 12 "ultra-rare" ones, that make skin pigmentation lighter, and an extremely rare, unique variant in a girl from Southern India, that caused red hair.


Then we have an area with a high level of Denisovan introgression, Melanesia where people have a different allele that causes fair hair and also red hair. It is a switch from arginine to cysteine known as the R93C mutation in the TYRP1 (tyrosinase-related protein 1) gene on chromosome 9. Did this mutation reach Polynesia in an ancient wave? I have posted about a pre-Maoir people who are said to have been the original inhabitants of New Zealand, the Urukehu, fair, and redheaded. Then we have the "Ehu" (note the term "ehu" in Urukehu, and Ehu. It means a reddish or brown tint in the hair) of Hawaii was reported by H. D. Alexander, 1893 (p.24): "The existence among them of a strain of lighter colored people with sandy or reddish hair called in Hawaii ehu and in New Zealand kehu may be due to intermingling with another race either in India or the Malay Archipelago."


The Denisovans could have reached America some 400,000 years ago, and adapted to the empty New World. These tule eaters could have been thei last remnants.


Giants


Reid believed they were giants, and the figures he calculated were gigantic. As I have shown, later, formal studies give them a tall yet normal height. This discrepancy requires an explanation.


In my first post, James Hart, who dug the caves, removing guano in 1911 unearthed very large skeletons: a man measuring 6 feet 6 inches (1.98 m), he described as gigantic. Where did this skeleton end up? It does not seem likely that it became part of Reid's collection, the one measured by modern scholars, which yielded "shorter" or more "normal" heights. The source I cited states that "It is assumed Reid must have collected these specimens from the Pyramid Lake area and in the Humboldt Sink. The time period to which these remains date is undetermined, as there were no directly associated artifacts or archaeological context. Consequently the skeletal material from the Reid Collection was grouped together and treated during this analysis as if all the individuals were from one time period." So, perhaps none of the cave people were measured, and Reid collected bones from Paiute burials in the region.


We will never know for certain because, as stated in the Humboldt Museum (Winnemucca, NV) website, "In respect for American Indians and compliance with NAGPRA, the display was removed. All human remains have been repatriated. HUMBOLDT MUSEUM DOES NOT POSSESS ANY HUMAN REMAINS OR FUNERARY ITEMS." The remains are lost to science in the name of a supposed (actually non-existent) link between Paiute people and these other humans who were not even Paiute!


The Modoc & Pit River connection


There were several references to the Modoc natives from Lake Tule and Pit River in the stories of the Paiute people about the redheaded giants. Why?


In my first post of this series I quoted Lowe and Harrington as saying "In the Mind of the Northern Paiute they [the tule-eaters] are often associated with the Pit River Indians among whom a remnant [of the redheaded giants] are even supposed to exist today. The Pit River Indians are called by the Paiute sai’i, which is also the name of the ancient people, but the possible reason for this is that both peoples are held in contempt." In other words, the Paiute gave the Modoc (Pit River Indians) the same name they had given the redhead giants: "sai'i" or "ancient". Which is revealing, because it assigns antiquity to these people, coinciding with the idea accepted by modern anthropologists, that they were the first inhabitants of this area of the Great Basin.


Lowe and Harrington also wrote that "The Northern Paiute applied to the ancient people the name sai-duka’a, “tule-eaters,” a name which might be applied to any people with this habit. This may account for the application of the name or its shortened form sai’i to the Pit River Indians and the form Saidyuka to Indians of eastern Oregon."


These Saidyuka were a small band, comprised of five tribes that lived close to Pyramid Lake in NW Nevada. that were displaced by the Paiute into Oregon (Source). They were of Shoshone origin, and therefore related to the Paiute, unlike the "ancient" lake dwellers.


In my second post I mentioned that bothh authors noted that "In some versions a few escaped and were chased to the northwest of Lovelock Cave; in other versions, they ended up as far away as Tule Lake, California."


In my third post, I quote Reid, who gives Gilbert Natchez's account: "the Piutes followed, and when they found that the intruders who Natchez called "Umatilla's" [sic] but other Piutes refer to as the Pitt River or Modoc Indians, had taken refuge in the cave... but other stories go on to state that the intruders were driven to the northwestward". Note that the Umatilla's did not have a river or lake habitat, instead they lived on the Columbia River plateau in Oregon, they used horses.


Reid also mentions that the "Si-te-cah (redheaded tule-eaters) ... who escaped this confrontation were driven north towards the Pitt River."


It seems that the "Pitt" (actually Pit) River natives, the Modoc people, who also lived by Lake Tule in NE California were considered tule-eaters. The versions stating that the survivors of Lovelock Cave massacre moved northwest, and the reference to the Umatilla people of southern Oregon all point at an association in the minds of the Paiutes, between the Nevada tule-eaters and those other ethnic groups, contemporary tribes, living in NE California and Oregon.


This association may have been promoted by the similar lifestyles of Modocs and Lovelock redheads, adapted to lake and river environments. But it is very likely that the Lovelock people did not belong to the Modoc, or Tulare, ethnic groups. They were the ancient inhabitants who settled there during the wet periods preceding the Last Glacial Maximum in the Great Basin Region.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Monday, October 12, 2026

Lovelock "giants" revisited (Post 4)


Today's is the fourth post in this series about the redheaded giants of Lovelock Cave, Nevada. In it, I will discuss some points mentioned by Reid and his sources about a local cryptid, and the belief held by Reid that these tule-eating giants were in fact Neanderthals.


This is the full series of posts on Lovelock Cave's "giants":

  • Post 1
  • Post 2
  • Post 3
  • Post 4
  • Post 5
  • Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)
  • January 2014 post mentioning Lovelock Cave.


Neanderthals


Dorothy P. Dansie published an article in the Nevada Historical Society Quarterly, Fall 1975, titled John T. Reid's Case for the Redheaded Giants. Besides the documents about readheaded giants, she also added some context, mentioning skulls that John Reid believed were Neanderthal skulls.


Dansie notes that Reid was a mine engineer and geologist, however, he didn't have any formal training in anthropology or archaeology, but he was a smart person and sought the advice and support of professional scholars.


She adds that "Reid's research had led him to believe he possessed Neanderthal skulls", so he wrote to the leading antrhropologist in America at that time, Ales Hrdlicka. Hrdlicka together with William Henry Holmes of the Smitshonian Institution, and Thomas Chamberlin of the United States Geological Survey, refused to accept that humans had reached America before the end of the last Ice Age, and placed their arrival around 3,000 to 10,000 years ago. So, when Reid wrote to him about the possibility that the skulls belonged to Neanderthals, Hrdlicka rejected the idea, and "simply referring Reid to Hrydlica's publications on the subject."


But Reid didn't give up. Dansie reports that "Reid had read of unusual skulls having been found in Illinois, Indiana and Iowa and also of General H. G. Thomas's exhumation of skulls in Dakota Territory "... like those of the great gibbon monkey..." So he sought advice elsewhere.


The Dakota Skulls of 1872


I will add some context to this statement about General Thomas and the Dakota Territory skulls.


These remains came from ancient Indian mounds. Cyrus Thomas (1825-1910) had an eclectic career, studying medicine, law, working as a school superintendent, and a Lutheran Evangelist minister. He helped found the Illinois Natural History in 1859 and in 1869, joined the Hayden Survey of the Northern Rockies as an entomologist. In 1873 he was appointed Professor of Natural History at Southern Illinois Normal University. In 1881 he was named Direcotr of the Division of Mound Exploration of the Bureau of Ethnology. (Source). It was during his service in North-Central USA in 1872, that he arrived at what then was the Dakota Territory (now North Dakota), and met General H. G. Thomas there. His account (which can be read in "Thomas, Cyrus 1873 Ancient mounds of Da ko ta. Geological Survey of the Territories for 1873. Government Printing Office, Washington, pp. 655-658) tells us that he was taveling in the Territory of Dakota in the summer of 1872, and learned about some mounds in the area. The local military force led by General H. G. Thomas provided him with support and Sioux guides and soldiers to help him excavate the mounds.


The mounds were, according to Cyrus, 2 miles southeast of Jamestown, North Dakota on Pipestone Creek (now named Pipestem Creek) see the approximate site in Google Maps.


Cyrus unearthed several human skeletons and drew a sketch of the mounds. He found nothing unsual. He also included a text written by General H. G. Thomas who had cut into some mounds before his arrival (Source); below I quote the relevant part of it; the highlight is mine:


"The crowning argument however comes with the skull. It is unlike that of any human being to day alive on this continent the frontal bone being low receding growing narrow and pinched from the brows up the top of the head depressed in the center. The cavity of the cranium is full seven inches long and a scant four and a half inches wide. The orbital ridges or eyebrows are excessively developed like those of the great Gibbon monkey. In fact the whole skull resembles that of the great Gibbon monkey.
HG THOMAS Captain Twentieth Infantry Brer Brig Gen USA
"


Thomas believed these were oddly shaped skulls was not that of a modern human being. Of course Reid would believe that these primitive skulls were those of Neanderthals.


So, we will return to our main story, back in Lovelock Nevada.


Neanderthal skulls in Lovelock


Dansie wrote that "during the summer of 1928 Reid was visited by S. de la Rue and Mary Sasse whom he claimed were well informed on the subject, having studied in museums in Europe. They took measurements of the skulls and " ... had no hesitation in pronouncing these Neanderthal. ... " They returned to Lovelock in 1929 and told Reid that they had submitted the skulls to various authorities before depositing them with the Museum of Natural History in New York and that they were more than ever convinced of their first evaluation".


So, these skulls never became part of the collection of the Nevada Historical Society in 1984, who acquired Reid's original collection. They ended up in New York City. I have not been able to find any information about S. de la Rue or Mary Sasse.


Dansie adds that "Dr. Clark Wissler, then Curator in Chief, Division of Anthropology at the Museum of Natural History, in due time informed Reid that the skeletons appeared to be of a type of early man (MS February 1, 1933)."


A newspaper article published in the Mason Valley News, Yerington, Nevada, 02 May 1931, titled Much Interest Taken in Lovelock History reports that Reid had said he'd found evidence of the presence of Mayan people in the region. It also mentions the 7 foot tall skeleton discovered nearby by Lloyd de la Montanya, and Reid's collection and the Lovelock cave redheaded giants, described as "red-heads, known scientifically as the Sid-ucah or Neanderthal race." You can read the article following the link above. Below is a cropped image.


Reid, Mayas, and Lovelake redheaded giants

The shape of the skulls


An interesting point is that Reid corresponded with Wissler and sent him bones and artifacts. In a letter dated October 1930, Reid wrote to Wissler about a grave where "another skull had been found, which Reid described as being that of a typical roundhead Indian distinctly different from the longheaded, redheaded people represented by the remains in the shipment (Letter, October 30, 1930, to Mr. Clark Wossler, Museum of Natural History, New York City, New York)."


This is a new fact about the redheaded people. Unlike the typical Indians like the Paiute, who had "round" skulls, that is, brachycephalic, the redheaded tule-eaters had elongated crania, that is, dolichocephalic.


Native Americans have both broad and long headed skulls (brachycephalic and dolichocephalic). Shape varies between regions, time periods, and ethnic groups, but the Paleoindians were mostly dolichocephalic. Only later did the natives shift towards rounder skulls (brachycephalic).


The skulls of Kennewick Man from Washington USA and Luzia, from Lagoa Santa, Brazil were dolichocephalic, and date back to around 10,000 years ago. They were paleoindians. The fact that later and modern Native Americans have rounded crania suggests that a second, more recent wave of migrants reache the Americas, and these were brachycephalic.


Intriguingly, (Boggione et al., 2025) Neanderthals and Denisovans (Qiang Ji et al., 2021) had elongated skulls, just like the ancient paleoindians had.


My next post will look into the local myths regarding a hominin-like monster that lived in that area.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Sunday, October 11, 2026

Lovelock "giants" revisited (Post 3)


In this, the third post on my series about the redheaded giant natives of Lovelock, Nevada, we will dissect the article by Dorothy P. Dansie, published in the Nevada Historical Society Quarterly, Fall 1975, titled John T. Reid's Case for the Redheaded Giants. It includes not only the quotes published by Lowe with Reid's account, and several native accounts on the redheaded Indians.


This is the full series of posts on Lovelock Cave's "giants":

  • Post 1
  • Post 2
  • Post 3
  • Post 4
  • Post 5
  • Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)
  • January 2014 post mentioning Lovelock Cave.


Dansie's Article - Main points


The article tells how John Reid, a local geologist, and mine engineer, who was born nearby in Nevada, and lived out his life there, provided the two expeditions (Lowe's in 1912 and Harrington's in 1924) that explored Lovelock cave with information about the local myths. Reid, who had worked at his father's General Store in Lovelock, spoke Paiute language and was a friend of the local Native Americans. This gave him intimate knowledge about their myths, lores, and also about the cave near the town of Lovelock.


Dansie, who read his files, says that Reid mentioned that the first time he visited the site was around 1866, as a boy, in the company of Gilbert Natches (or Natchez), a relative of Sarah Winnemucca and a Paiute. Gilbert was accompanied by other natives, and the party was searching for wild horses. They camped by the cave, and Natchez told Reid the following story (highlighting is mine):


"A long time ago an indian [sic] tribe came into this country from the southward, this indian tribe was redheaded and they were very tall men, the Piutes fought them on the south and west side of the lake that the intruders crossed over the lake and into the cave, by the use of tule boats they were able to cross the lake easily. The Piutes followed, and when they found that the intruders who Natchez called "Umatilla's" [sic] but other Piutes refer to as the Pitt River or Modoc Indians, had taken refuge in the cave , then the Piutes gathered in council and decided that they would gather all of the sagebrush that they could get hold of that lay to the east of and above the cave and after placing this on the bluff above and setting it afire that they would continue to throw over lighted brush into the face of the cave until all within had perished from suffocation all the while having men so posted that any of the people within the cave trying to escape could be killed with well directed arrows. After a siege lasting several days, Natches [sic] relates that all of the intruders were killed, but other stories go on to state that the intruders were driven to the northwestward. I can only reconcile this lack of harmony in the different stories with the probable fact that where the battles took place to the southward of Humboldt Lake, it is more than probable that the intruders had their force divided into two groups', one of which went on the east side of the lake while the other went on the west side of the lake .... (MS August 8,1924, "Notes for Mr. Harrington")."


The origin of these "readheaded-giant" is relevant. Reid says that according to his Paiute friends, they came from the Southwest (as seen from Lovelock, Nevada). I prepared the following map to show the places mentioned in this text. Lovelock is the red star, in Nevada (Yellow), the southwestern direction is the Triangle to the lower left of the map, into California. Pitt River (also known as Pit River) is located in northeastern California, and flows into the Sacramento River. It runs through Modoc County. Both are mentioned by Reid as names given to these Indians by the Paiute. Interestingly (as mentioned in my previous posts), Sarah Winnemucca said these people were Tule eaters and lived on Humboldt Lake weaving tule bulrushes, living on tule islands, with tule boats. There are two lakes associated to the word tule, one is Lake Tulare, near modern Tulare and Fresno in California, now dissecated, a former lake and vast wetland fed by the snowmelt of the Sierra Nevada in California, and the San Joaquin River basin. The other in northern California has also been partly dissecated, and is located just beyond the western tip of Modoc County.


map Tule eating Indians and Lovelock Cave locations
Map with the places mentioned in this text. Copyright ©2026 by Austin Whittall

Since Modoc and Pit River are northwest of Lovelock, something does not fit. I believe that the Paiute found the Modoc tule-eaters similar to others "that came from the southwest", possibly from the region of Lake Tulare, in California (see map).


However, another story has them coming from the Modoc region as we will see below.


In this story, Reid tells us about a man named Dick Sampson, who was around 75 years old in 1924, who recalled a tale told to him by his great-grandmother about the battles between Paiute and these other (readheaded) natives. This time, we learn they came from the west, from Pit River: "She had told Sampson that those now called "Pitt River Indians" came in from the west" and that after several battles"They finally departed westward, back to Pitt River where they had come from".


They weren't redheaded either: "Sampson told Reid that he had never heard that those people whom the Paiutes killed at the cave above Humboldt Lake were redheaded, as had been stated by Chief Natchez." This ties in with the Modoc region, but depicts them as regular natives.


Reid also had other accounts by people who lived in the region. They said that the "Si-te-cah (redheaded tule-eaters) ... who escaped this confrontation were driven north towards the Pitt River."


But, unlike other versions, these tule-eaters spoke a different language; "Virginia" Jim recalled that they had called out to the Paiute "in mournful tones, " Yah-hah-nah-ho-week-ho-no," as well as he could remember it, but that he did not understand its meaning nor did the ancestors who told him of the incident. He thought it was a plea for peace."


In another story, a civil engineer named L. H. Taylor, recalled that in 1904, an old Indian told him about the fighting between the Paiute and "the people who had been in the area when the Indians came."


This suggests that these tule-eaters were the first, the original people living there before the arrival of the Paiute.


This fighting took place along Carson River (that runs from the eastern slopes of the Sierra Nevada south of Lake Tahoe, with a NE course into Nevada, draining into a closed basin (Carson Sink) south of Lovelock. This aligns with the SW direction mentioned further up.


The habitat of the tule-eaters was the lakes, rivers, and wetlands in west-central Nevada beyond Lake Humboldt. This idea is reinforced by another statement recorded by Reid, given by James Hunter from Lovelock, who had been told by a Paiute named Bung-Eye-Jim that: the Paiute asked other tribes of the intermuntain region for help, and they provided it, sending reinforcements to cover the Paiute losses, "to assist in an all-out effort to exterminate the enemy. Cooperation seemed assured because other tribes had exterminated the redheaded people in the surrounding territories and the antipathy toward them would lend impetus to the plan for final genocide."


The "Intermountain Region" spans California east of the Sierra Nevada, Nevada, Utah, and Colorado west of the Rocky mountains. It extends north and south between the Cascades and the Rockies (Washington, Oregon, Idaho, west Montana and Wyoming, Northern Arizona and Western New Mexico). The natives living here detested these tule-eating people. Why?

Sarah Winemmucca's red-hair dress


I have already mentioned that Sarah Winemmucca said she owned a dress made with the red hair of these defeated people. Reid had more information about this weird garment.


A native named Mr. Mah-Wee made a statement in 1927, who was around 76 years (or more) at that time. He was questioned by Reid, and the statement was witnessed by a government surveyor named John Runner. This was the statement; Reid asked the questions, Mah-Wee answered them:


"Question: Do you remember anything pertaining to a dress that Sarah Winnemucca had that was made of human hair?
Answer: I do.
Question: What was the color of the dress?
Answer: It was red.
Question: Was it a light or a dark red?
Answer: It was a brownish red.
Question: Describe this dress.
Answer: It was like a shirt dress.
Question: What became of this dress?
Answer: I do not know.
Question: How did Sarah W. Hopkins get this dress?
Answer: From the Sai-te-cah (Tule Eaters)
Question: What was the color of these people's hair?
Answer: It was reddish-brown, or a brownish-red.
Question: Did you ever talk directly to Sarah Winnemucca as to how it was that this came to be handed down to her?
Answer: We were not inquisitive and did not ask many questions as you people do as to what happened in the past, but, I remember the dress very well.
Question: How long was the hair in the dress?
Answer: It was made up of hair of various lengths, from a few inches in length to two or more feet in length.
Question: Where is Sarah Winnemucca buried?
Answer: I heard she was buried in Oregon or Idaho, or some place afar off.
(MS December 31, 1927)
"


So this witness says these people had red hair, and that Winnemucca's dress existed. It would invalidate the version that the hair of the remains found in Lovelock cave was red due to aging (chemicals, exposure, etc) or ochre.


Reid also recorded that Jasper Wright had told him that about 1920 Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins was with Yellow Tail at one of the Wyoming reservations above Riverton, near Casper, and she was wearing one of the coats with red hair." Sam Dick noted in 1930 "that the Si-te-cah dressed in those coats but the Indians did not."


Another account by a Paiute called Bow-E-An (aka "Skinny Dave"), grandson of Natchez and great-nephew of Winnemucca, narrated how his father, Pas-sa Dave (aka "Captain Dave") about "people who had lived by the Humboldt and Carson Lakes in his great-great-grandfather's time. They had reddish brown hair. He said that some of them were about the height of Paiutes, but others were very tall. These people were called Si-te-cah which means "Tule Eaters." These people lived principally upon the lakes where they had boats made of tules and upon these boats there were built thatched houses made of tules. The boats could be bound together so that the people could step from one boat to the other as on rafts. However, the boats could be detached readily. The Si-te-cah seldom left the rafts except to procure necessities such as seeds and the stones for grinding them. The Paiutes, whom they feared , kept them hemmed in for a great many years."


Captain Dave met these people and they gave him some gifts: "... beads, a moccasin made of badger skin, arrow points made of sea shell, foodstuff, and a small dog which had ears that stood up straight. The Paiutes did not have any dogs. Since the dog warned the Paiutes of anything coming from far off, they thought he was pretty smart. [he] also brought lots of different things made of mud hen skins, such as neck bands of flowing feathers, and beaver blankets... There were a great number of the redheaded people who in the early mornings and evenings made cooking fires, whereas the Indians ate most of their food raw having no regular time for building fires as did the people destined to become their mortal enemies"


This story mentions the use of dogs by the tule-eaters but not by the Paiute, and that they also employed fire, which the Paiute didn't. Strange indeed!


Tall skeleton


In 1931, Reid learned about a skeleton in the lake bed close to the cave. He dug it up, it was "a large skeleton... 7 feet 7 or 6 inches in height. The difference of one inch ... is due to the matter of being unable to determine if the toes, lying upward, had been bent or were erect" A few months later "Lloyd De La Montoya of California had discovered the skeleton of a "giant" on the lake bed near Toy." Reid measured its femora and "deduced that this man had been "nine and one half or possibly ten feet" tall." Really tall! (2.9 to 3.05 m tall)


The article includes curious information about native monster myths and Reid's theory linking these giants to Neanderthals, which I will discuss in my next post.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Friday, October 9, 2026

Lovelock "giants" revisited (Post 2)


This is the second post in this series of posts about the redheaded giant Indians discovered in Lovelock Cave, Nevada in the early 1900s. My first post commented the account given by the local Paiute natives, as recorded in Sarah Winnemucca's book, published in 1883, the scientific report onthe excavation sin Lovelock Cave by Lowe and Harrington in 1929, and John T. Reid, a local geologist and anthropologist who had explored the site and spoke to the guano miners who discovered it in 1911.


This is the full series of posts on Lovelock Cave's "giants":

  • Post 1
  • Post 2
  • Post 3
  • Post 4
  • Post 5
  • Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)
  • January 2014 post mentioning Lovelock Cave.


The giants were not so gigantic


I found more information about Reid and the redheaded giants, in an article titled John Reid's Redheaded "Giants" of Central Nevada: Fact or Fiction? by Sheilagh Brooks, Carolyn Stark and Richard H. Brooks, published in the Nevada Historical Society Quarterly of Fall 1984. The authors analyze the size of the bones unearthed at Lovelock Cave and conclude they were not giants. They also try to explain the red color of these people (they were redheaded).


Lovelock Cave
Lovelock Cave. Ken Lund

Background


Reid collected bones from many sites in this region in northwestern-central Nevada over the course of the years. His private collection included many artifacts too, but the core of it were the fourteen skulls and skeletons of this readheaded group of natives. The collection was acquired in 1984 by the Nevada Historical Society, and analyzed in depth.


The article sites Reid's biography by James Graves Scrugham, published in 1935 who wrote: "One of his great finds was a skeleton, found ahout twenty miles southerly of Lovelock, Nevada, showing that the body of which it was a framework, was exactly seven feet, seven inches tail. It is one of the "giant men" of an ancient race of which skeletons were unearthed in Central Nevada. (1935:228-229)" This is a remarkable height 7 ft. 7" is 2.31 meters tall!


The book then describes the tribe to which this person belonged, they seem to summarize the information provided by Winnemucca and Natchez that I transcribed in my first post:


"... a race of extremely tall redhaired people, referred to as Tule Eaters, who lived in the Humboldt Sink area. These people frequently were described as cruel, wicked, and possibly cannibalistic. Supposedly the Northern Paiutes feared and hated them. According to one version of the story, fighting broke out between the Giants and the Northern Paiutes. The Northern Paiutes chased the Giants into Lovelock Cave and covered the entrance with brush, which they fired to suffocate the Giants. Those Giants who tried to get out of the cave were shot by the Northern Paiutes' best marksmen. Some of the Giants did escape, and the fighting continued into the Humboldt Sink and around Pyramid Lake. All of the male Giants were killed, but a few of the females survived and later mated with Northern Paiute men. In some versions a few escaped and were chased to the northwest of Lovelock Cave; in other versions, they ended up as far away as Tule Lake, California."


I highlighted a new piece of information, that the surviving "giant" women were taken into the Paiute tribe as brides, and, the other version, that some escaped to Tule Lake in California. This lake (see it in Google maps) is 320 km (200 mi.) northwest of Lovelock, close to the California-Oregon state line.


Why did Reid conclude that these people were giants? He measured their femora (thigh bones) and compared them with his knee-to-hip distance. Simple maths lead him to calculate heights ranging from 7 ft. 7" to 9 ft. 6", 2.31 m to 2.9 m. These were tall men!


The hair was also reddish: "Hair is preserved on some of the skulls, which still have soft tissues adhering. The hair is a brownish red in color, confirming the description in the Redheaded Giant stories of these people being red haired. Because of his size estimates and the hair color, Reid was certain that he had found and identified the Redheaded Giants described in the Northern Paiute stories he had heard in his youth."


Many of the bones don't belong to complete skeletons, and the exact origin of many of them is unknown. Not all of them came from Lovelock Cave. The authors assume, that they came from Lake Humboldt and Lake Pyramid region, but are not certain of their provenance.


Furthermore, their dating is not known. They could be remains spanning tousands of years, from different ethnic groups. The authors treat them as belonging to a single time period. With these caveats, they concluded that the remains were of a normal stature. Not giants.


Only six male specimens had femora, and these were measured and using a formula devised by Trotter and Gleser, they estimated the height of these individuals, using left and right thigh bones, the range of heights was: 1.66 m to 1.79 m (5 ft 5" to 5 ft 11") plus minus 2" (5 cm). These are similar to other remains collected in the region in known sites.


The authors conclude that "some of the individual males were relatively tall" but the calculated values "in no way qualifies those persons as giants. Also, others were short for males..."


Their hair was red


The remains had red hair, and the article has two explanations: (1) the use of ochre, and (2) chemical action by natural decomposition and mummification.


"In the Reid Collection there are semi-mummified skeletons, and also in the burials recovered from Lovelock Cave by Loud and Harrington (1929). These are natural mummies, preserved by the arid climate. The hair of the mummies in the Reid Collection, when preserved, is a reddish-brown color. From archaeological research, and from ethno-historical accounts, data have been accumulated demonstrating that many of the Great Basin Native American Indian groups painted themselves while alive, and also painted their dead, with red ochre.
Red ochre is a mineral paint which colors anything a reddish-brown or orangish-brown shade. The significance of red ochre is that as a mineral it will not disintegrate, if placed on a body prior to burial, when the soft tissues deteriorate. If the body becomes fully skeletalized, the red ochre will then stain the bones after the soft tissues have gone. Red ochre also will color hair, changing black hair into a reddish or rusty-brown shade.
Also after burial, either during the drying out of the soft tissues of the body, or during their disintegration, these tissues release various fluids, which will dye or stain hair if it is preserved. One component of these fluids is ammonia, which dyes black hair a reddish or orangish shade.
Either one or both of these methods of staining preserved hair could have affected the mummies in the Reid Collection, and also those collected hy Loud and Harrington (1929) from Lovelock Cave. This reddish or rusty-brown coloring for the hair of mummies is not unusual in regions where the natural aridity of the climate has preserved the bodies and the hair as natural mummies.
"


The explanations sound reasonable. Ochre has been used by humans and other hominins over hundreds of thousands of years, and natural processes can change the color of hair. There has been speculation about readheaded Amerindians (see this post, and this post), and mythical redheaded creatures among Native Americans, like the Trauco or the Corupira) but no tangible archaeological proof of their existence.


The 1984 article concludes that "The archaeological materials associated with the burials removed by Loud and Harrington are of types expected to occur in that area of the Great Basin at that prehistoric time period. There is no substantiation that a group of people with a differing culture pattern, who might fit the description in the stories of Redheaded Giants, lived in Lovelock Cave, Pyramid Lake, or Humboldt Sink during the prehistoric period. Nor is there any evidence of death by violence observed on the skeletons of the Reid Collection, and the description of the burials found by Loud and Harrington indicates that they originally had been carefully prepared for burial".


My next post, the third in this series will follow an article by Dorothy Dansie, published in 1975, with more sources on John Reid and the redheaded giants.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Thursday, October 8, 2026

Lovelock "giants" revisited (Post 1)


Nearly 17 years ago I wrote a post about the Lovelock Skull and Spirit Cave Man - Nevada and quoted a short paragraph form a book written by a Paiute woman named Sarah Hopinks Winnemucca in 1883: Life among the Piutes, their wrongs and claims. Putnam’s. N. York. p 73. In it she describes how her people fought against a "small tribe of barbarians" who were cannibals, and who "had reddish hair". I remarked that redheadedness was uncommon among Amerindians but that Neanderthals carried a gene responsible for red tinted hair and suggested that "maybe a band of relict Neanderthals lived in Nevada until quite recently and were wiped out by the Paiute."


The story is longer and far more entertaining than my brief post revealed. Today's post is the first of a series that will look into other sources about these redheaded Indians, which, according to some witnesses, were giants.


This is the full series of posts on Lovelock Cave's "giants":

  • Post 1
  • Post 2
  • Post 3
  • Post 4
  • Post 5
  • Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)
  • January 2014 post mentioning Lovelock Cave.


The Version given by Sarah Winnemucca: Redheaded Cannibals


Sarah Winnemucca in 1883, portrait
Sarah Winnemucca, 1883 portrait. Source

This is what Sarah Winnemucca (1841-1895) wrote in her book (she had learned to read and write in English at a Mormon school in Genoa, Nevada):


"Among the traditions of our people is one of a small tribe of barbarians who used to live along the Humboldt River. It was many hundred years ago. They used to waylay my people and kill and eat them. They would dig large holes in our trails at night, and if any of our people travelled at night, which they did, for they were afraid of these barbarous people, they would oftentimes fall into these holes. That tribe would even eat their own dead —yes, they would even come and dig up our dead after they were buried, and would carry them off and eat them. Now and then they would come and make war on my people. They would fight, and as fast as they killed one another on either side, the women would carry off those who were killed. My people say they were very brave. When they were fighting they would jump up in the air after the arrows that went over their heads, and shoot the same arrows back again. My people took some of them into their families, but they could not make them like themselves. So at last they made war on them. This war lasted a long time. Their number was about twenty-six hundred (2600). The war lasted some three years. My people killed them in great numbers, and what few were left went into the thick bush. My people set the bush on fire. This was right above Humboldt Lake."


So, here we hava a band of "bararians", "Barbarous people", who were cannibals, warmongering and "very brave". The Paiute tried to integrate them but they couldn't adapt. The story goes on, describing how the barbarians fled in boats made from bulrushes known as Tule, across Lake Humboldt, and were picked off by the Paiute as they landed. They hid in a cave (Lovelock Cave) and were killed every time they left the cave to fetch water. The Paiute asked them if they'd quit their bad ways: "My people would ask them if they would be like us, and not eat people like coyotes or beasts. They talked the same language, but they would not give up." So finally they gathered wood and dry bushes and burned them alive in their cave. Winnemucca added: "This tribe was called people-eaters".


This took place in west-central Nevada, not far from its capital city, Reno. See Humboldt Lake in Google Maps. The map also shows the location of Lovelock Cave. The area is now barren, but during the period following the last Ice Age, it was a well watered region with lakes (the lake is pictured below, Source).


lake Humboldt, Nevada, USA

Winnemucca's red hair dress


Then she mentions that they were redheaded and that she owned a dress made from their hair!


"My people say that the tribe we exterminated had reddish hair. I have some of their hair, which has been handed down from father to son. I have a dress which has been in our family a great many years, trimmed with this reddish hair. I am going to wear it some time when I lecture. It is called the mourning dress, and no one has such a dress but my family."


The discovery of Lovelock Cave


The cave is mentioned by Llewllyn L. Loud and M.R. Harrington in their scholarly account about their excavations at the cave (See their book: Lovelock Cave, 1929. For a full description of their activities there).


Loud visited the site in 1911 once the mining of bat guano from the cave had concluded. During the mining period, bones and artifacts had been found in the cave, and many were destroyed, lost, or sold to private collectors. Starting in 1912, Loud recovered thousands of artifacts. In 1924, a new expedition conducted by Harrington went to the cave, Loude assisted him. The book includes accounts given by Gilbert Natches in 1914, Gilbert was the grandson of Sarah Winnemucca, her account about the cave, and the story of its discovery by White men, given by John. T. Reid.


Interestingly, Gilbert Natches mentioned a Paiute myth about abstaining from killing bears and using their fur: "bear meat was never eaten, because bears are just the same as a person. They understand our language and know when they are being talked about even at a distance." This is similar to what Winnemucca had said about the man-eaters "They talked the same language" as the Paiute. So maybe the redheaded people didn't speak the Paiute language.


Lowe and Harrington report the Paiute's belief in "supernatural creatures", who attributed to them the stone tools made in different shapes, and from different types of stones to the ones they knapped:


"They had spears and no arrows, while the Northern Paiute had arrows but no spears. They were mean, contemptible, foolish, degraded cannibals, had red hair which they were excessively fond of decorating with bone ornaments, and yet w'ere so poor that they dressed in robes made of the skin and feathers of the mud hen. In a collection of specimens from Nevada every object w'hich is unfamiliar to a Northern Paiute is attributed to them.
In the mind of the Northern Paiute they are often associated with the Pit River Indians among whom a remnant are even supposed to exist today. The Pit River Indians are called by the Paiute sai’i, which is also the name of the ancient people, but the possible reason for this is that both peoples are held in contempt.
Of the ancient sai ’i there were two bands. The first band, which is conceived, like any band or “family” of Northern Paiute, to consist of only a few hundred individuals, lived at Humboldt lake until exterminated by the Northern Paiute...
" [Source]


The book mentions Sarah Winnemucca's account (transcribed further up) including it as Appendix III, and reports that Gilbert had heard this same account from his grandmother who had learned it from her grandfather.


Lowe comments on Sarah's story and notes that " Much of the hair found on the mummies in the cave is reddish. Similar hair is known from mummies from the Pueblo region, Peru, and elsewhere, the color being due to age or chemical action." He also notes that "The Northern Paiute applied to the ancient people the name sai-duka’a, “tule-eaters,” a name which might be applied to any people with this habit. This may account for the application of the name or its shortened form sai’i to the Pit River Indians and the form Saidyuka to Indians of eastern Oregon".


Tule (Schoenoplectus acutus) is a variety of bulrush that grows in North America and which the natives used to weave baskets, mats, clothes, tents, and watercaraft. The tender shoots can be eaten, and the roots (rhizomes) and flowers are boiled like vegetables. The old, tough roots, can be boiled and mashed to remove the fiber to produce flour. So the name "tule eaters" or Sai-duka'a (also written Si-Te-Cah) given to these people is quite reasonable.


Finally, in Appendix IV, it gives "John T. Reid’s Accounts Of Lovelock Cave" which we will discuss below.


John T. Reid


John T. Reid, born in 1871 in Unionville, Nevada, died 1943 in Lovelock, Nevada. His father ran the General Store there between 1883 and 1895, and John was a clerk. He later became a geologist and mining engineer. His intimate knowledge of the natives and his interest in anthropology and archaeology led him to investigate the local sites, and also befriend the natives. Below is his portrait.


John T. Reid
John T. Reid, portrait. Source

This is the account given by Reid to Lowe (Source). Captain Natches is Gilbert Natches. Highlight is mine:


"I recall that along about 1887, when I was about 16 years old, Captain Natches, two other Indians, one known locally as “Coffee Charley,” the other as “Mustache Charley,” and myself had undertaken to catch some wild horses that roamed in the neighborhood of the Carson and Humboldt sinks. In due time we came in contact with the wild horses, and then the chase was on. After running those horses all day long we were obliged to camp over night near the southern end of the Humboldt sink and on its eastern shore. The next morning we resumed the chase, following the horses over into the Carson Sink desert. But here we had to turn around, homeward bound, since we had no fresh saddle horses available to pursue the mustangs further.
On the way back we passed Lovelock cave, and the hour being late wo decided to camp there for the night. Later, Captain Natches related to me the great calamity which had occurred in that cave to another race of people who had been exterminated by the Piutes.
In the tale that Natches related, with the other two Indians aiding him in bringing out all of the material facts that had any connection, I was informed that about four or five generations back the Indians had fought to extermination a people who were redheaded and who spoke their own language. The fact that these two people spoke tho same language suggests that they had lived together for a long period of time.
Natches assigned no reason for the origin of the trouble between the two races, and I doubt if he knew or had a history, although his sister, Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins, states that these people were cannibals and ate the Piutes. This is hardly compatible with her further statement that the Piutes had taken some of these people into their own families.
Annie Lowry, a half breed, who married an Indian named Mr. Sanny, assigned as a reason for the trouble between the two races that these people had stolen their women and taken their wild rice seed away from them.
I rather think that the matter of food was the trouble and the Piutes decided after a period of droughts that they would exterminate the other people who were consumers of the small amount, that was all the while getting smaller and smaller, of food that was available in the form of wild seeds and wild fowl that visited the lakes.
Natches stated that these people had come from the southwest. A battle had waged for a long time on the Carson sink at some sand hills on the east and west side of the Carson river, after which the Piutes had driven these people northward into the region of the Humboldt lake, thence across the lake to the cave, some going into the cave while others went northward.
From what I learned through Natches, and from numerous others of the old Indians, I have deduced that this redheaded people had long occupied the territory about the cave before the Piute Indian had come from elsewhere.
Natches further related how the Piute Indians had gathered sagebrush in great quantity around and about the hills adjacent to the cave and assembled it on the bluff above the cave. Then they had lighted and thrown it down immediately in front of the cave. The Piutes staid on either side of the cave, at a safe distance, and watched for the people within to come out for food or water, or to escape the smoke which in part penetrated the cave. As they came out they were dispatched with well-directed arrows.
"


The story told to Reid by Gilbert Natches and his companions is identical to the one told by Sarah Winnemucca. But it seems that some of the readheaded people managed to escape unharmed fleeing north.


Lowe then transcribes an account that John Reid had heard from James H. Hart (Source). Hart and David Pugh filed a mineral claim on the cave to mine bat guano deposits in 1911. James Hart said:


"In 1911 I heard David Pugh of Lovelock tell of an old Indian cave some twenty miles south of Lovelock. He said that it was full of bat guano in which he had dug down four feet. When a boy he had learnt from the Indians where the cave was. There had then been fires in it for there was much smoke on the walls. Realizing that if the cave was as large as described the guano might be of value, I arranged with Pugh to file a mineral location upon it and ship out the guano. This we did, working from the fall of 1911 to the spring of 1912. We drove a small tunnel into the mouth of the cave, or rather to one side of it, the natural opening being too small to work through. We took out about five car-loads of guano which were shipped to the Hawaiian Fertilizer Company of San Francisco. Wd soon began to discover Indian relics, and notified Dr. J. C. Merriam of the University of California, who took the matter up with the University of Nevada and the Nevada Historical Society. We also wrote to the Smithsonian Institution, but they advised that they had no funds for collecting, receiving only donations. After some of the best specimens had been destroyed, we received word from the State Historical Society that, in conjunction with the University of California, they would send an investigator. This was Mr. Loud. We gave him all possible facilities for collecting. Many objects had been destroyed by the weather and others had been taken away. I recall many boas or ropes of fine feathers. As these lay strewn about in the open end of the cave in the way of the workmen they were irreparably damaged. Some of these boas were found perfectly preserved. All the Indian objects began to appear about four feet below the surface of the guano.
In the south end of the cave, "about twenty feet deep," we unearthed some skeletons. In the north-central part of the cave, about four feet deep, was a striking looking body of a man "six feet six inches tall." His body was mummified and his hair distinctly red. There was a grass rope about his neck with a knot under the left ear. The rope was about eight feet long. The feet were bound together from the ankle to above the knees with stout rope. The mummification was complete except for a part of the abdomen. The other mummies all had red hair — I think there were either four or five. Those that appeared to be women were small, something like a Japanese woman in height." This was not altogether due to the shrinking of the bodies in mummifying, because the man was “a giant.” The women had on moccasins which reached clear to the knees; the buckskin was beaded with shells. Two of them had on a kind of buckskin coat (gown) that came down to the knees. These bodies were from the deep south end of the cave.
There were no bats in the cave when we went there to work.
"


This is an eyewitness account of giant men six feet, six inches tall (1.98 m) which isn't gigantic, but, is tall. The women were smaller, suggesting sexual dimorphism, which isn't overly marked in humans but noticeable in other primates.


I also highlighted the remark about bats, let's see the relevance of bats in this story.


Bats and the date of the site


The arid and desert-like environment of Lake Humboldt, there are bats, like the little brown bat (Myotis lucifugus) in NW Nevada. They migrate and hibernate but live in small groups. There are over 20 bat species living in the state of Nevada. Any of them could have lived in the cave.


Bat excrement accumulates on the floor of the cave, beneath the bats hanging from the ceiling. This cave had 3 to 6 feet (90 to 180 cm) of guano (bat droppings, used as fertilizer) on its floor (see p. 8). But, as mentioned by Hart, in 1911 there were no bats in the cave. The accumulation of guano may have been old.


How quickly does guano accumulate in a cave? This depends on many factors. The seasonality of the bat population (do they live in the cave on a permanent basis, or move to other sites?), the population itself, and the cave chemistry. An example reported by Bogdanowicz et al., 2020 dated guano in two caves in Jamaica. In one, a core 81 cm long was dated to 200 years old, in the other, a 1.29 m long core was found to be 4300 years old. This confirms the different deposition speeds (4 mm per year in cave #1 and 0.3 mm per year in cave #2, a thirteen-fold difference.


Six feet of guano would have accumulated over a period of 450 to 6,000 years using the values given by Bogdanowicz. But it could have been even thicker; Lowe reports that "Before the arrival of the writer, 5 carloads of 50 (?) tons each had been taken from the cave for fertilizer. Besides this, a large quantity was left in the cave because it was so much mixed with other things that it no longer paid to ship it. Bat manure was sometimes found in nearly pure beds of perhaps several feet thickness." (p. 34) Lowe adds that "Although there was so large a quantity of bat guano in the cave no bats were seen during the writer’s stay; but a cowboy said that several years previously he had smoked out large numbers." Lowe and Hart saw no bats, is it reasonable to believe that they had been smoked out in the past?


While dealing with the bat excrement, Lowe says that "The human excrement in the cave reveals, on the part of the ancient inhabitants, an incredibly coarse diet of seeds, hulls, and tough plant fibers. Some of the excrement was over 2 inches in diameter." An amazingly fibrous diet, but also, weirdly large sized stool. Were these people human beings, or some plant-eating primate?


The bats, according to Shackley, M. Steven n.d. occupied the caves shortly after a wet period 7.000 years ago: "Heizer and Napton state that Lovelock Cave was occupied by bats at a date coinciding with the estimated end of the Altithermal perhaps as a direct result of the rejuvenation of Humboldt Lake. The initial buildup of the older bat guano layer may have begun ca. 5000 B. C. The earliest, although intermittent evidence of human occupation is in the Older Guano layer at ca. 2700 B. C. Bats and other creatures continued to inhabit the cave until about 2500 B. C. when human occupation began ca. 1500 B. C... Intensive occupation of the cave began ca. 1500 B. C. and continued until about A. D. 500. Due to a massive rockfall (ca. A. D. 440 ± 90) access to the interior of the cave was greatly impeded, but it continued to be utilized as a repository for the dead and for cache purposes. According to Heizer and Napton (1970: 41), human occupation of the interior of the cave was drastically curtailed, and this, together with the reduced illumination and air circulation made it attractive to bats. Thus, between A. D. 700 and A. D. 1911, a thick deposit of bat guano accumulated over the cultural deposits. Human occupation of the outer shelter and use of the inner cave probably continued until 1829."


So there is an "old" and a "new" period of guano buildup, one prior to 2,500 BC, the other after 700 AD. These are relatively recent.


In the second part of this series of posts, we will look into more information about Reid and the redheaded giants, following John Reid's Redheaded "Giants" of Central Nevada: Fact or Fiction? by Sheilagh Brooks, Carolyn Stark and Richard H. Brooks, 1984. The authors conclude that the people buried in Lovelock cave were not giants and also explain their origin of their reddish hair.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 
Hits since Sept. 2009:
Copyright © 2009-2025 by Austin Victor Whittall.
Todos los derechos reservados por Austin Whittall para esta edición en idioma español y / o inglés. No se permite la reproducción parcial o total, el almacenamiento, el alquiler, la transmisión o la transformación de este libro, en cualquier forma o por cualquier medio, sea electrónico o mecánico, mediante fotocopias, digitalización u otros métodos, sin el permiso previo y escrito del autor, excepto por un periodista, quien puede tomar cortos pasajes para ser usados en un comentario sobre esta obra para ser publicado en una revista o periódico. Su infracción está penada por las leyes 11.723 y 25.446.

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means - electronic, mechanical, photocopy, recording, or any other - except for brief quotations in printed reviews, without prior written permission from the author, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review.

Please read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy before accessing this blog.

Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy

Patagonian Monsters - https://patagoniamonsters.blogspot.com/