I really enjoy watching documentaries on TV, like those aired on Discovery or History Channel. Last night I smirked my way through one about "ancient astronauts", not because I believe in them (I don't), but because I was surprised at the farfetched conjectures put forward by the likes of Giorgio A. Tsoukalos and David Hatcher Childress. They weave fantastic stories and present them as if they were proven facts. Below I will dissect one of the things that they sold as if it was science, but has absolutely no scientific basis at all.
Some background
My first encounter with ancient artifacts attributed to extraterrestrials or alien contact happened in the 1970s. I was a gullible teenager and with my school mates we read all we could about UFOs, including a local (Argentine) magazine Cuarta Dimension (by another windbag: Fabio Zerpa). Among the books that I read, were two by Erich von Däniken (The Gold of the Gods, and Chariots of the Gods). Although I was fourteen years old, I was a bit skeptical about the idea that aliens had visited all these ancient people (from Peru, and Mesoamerica, to China, Egypt and the Middle East), imprinted the god myths in each culture, left absolutely no physical evidence of their presence, and vanished. Yet, the humans "replicated" or "reproduced" the artifacts these alien gods had displayed, creating depictions of winged creatures and birdmen (to show how these aliens flew), and objects that von Däniken interpreted as electric batteries, golden planes, men with astronaut helmets, computer chips, Nazca Lines, etc. I found it rather hard to believe they'd build pyramids in stone and other regular stone age stuff, but leave no high-tech artifacts stowed in some cache that would have been found by now, and cracked open using modern science (read Arthur C. Clarke's The Sentinel, which later led to some of the opening scenes of 2001: A Space Odyssey, which elaborate on how one would expect extraterrestrial intelligences would leave unequivocal evidence of their visit to Earth, and its Moon). Yes, in case you are wondering, I am an ardent fan of sci-fi, and Clarke, toghether with Asimov, Heinlein, and Bradbury were, and still are, some of my favorite authors of sci-fi.
Nowadays I do not believe in aliens visiting Earth, or alien contact, or artifacts hidden away by evil governments in warehouses like Area 51. I am open minded, and wonder, like Fermi did, when he asked back in 1950 "Where is everybody?." The maths (see Drake's equation) are impressive, and we must live in a Universe with several thousand advanced alien civilizations... but, we seem to all be stranded on our home planets, 50 years ago reached the most distant point yet from Earth, 1 light day, and that is nothing. The distance to the nearest star, Alpha Centauri is 1595 light days from us... or 80,000 years going at the speed of Voyager 1.
Birdmen
Yesterday's TV program was about winged birdlike creatures, said to represent the flying abilities of extraterrestrial visitors (wings = flight = UFOs flying). Of course, some winged guys had bird heads topping a human body, like the Egyptian gods Toth, with an ibis head or Horus with that of a hawk; but others had wings with human heads or bird heads and wings (Assyria) or no wings at all (Olmecs). So, what is the common denominator? Birdlike features? And we must surmise that this implies ET visitors?
But if this is the case, then, what do the other gods represent? For instance winged bulls from Assyria or the jackal headed Anubis, and Sobek the cow, or the feathered snake of the Mesoamericans? Mutant gods? Or, more likely, antropomorph depictions of the animals that were relevant to a particular culture. Birdmen could be just that, birds represented as humans, with no link to aliens.
The "purse"
An interesting fact mentioned in the program was an object called a purse, because that is what it looks like, a small box-like pouch hanging from a semicircular handle or strap. A common object, used by humans for tens of thousands of years (from hunter gatherers to modern women with Louis Vuitton purses) because it is practical and easy to make. But, in this instance, the alien "theorists" suggested that the object had some alien high tech in it, and was a symbol of extraterrestrial gods. These objects were shown in different stone engravings, from different parts of the world. Below you can see them:
The image on the right, is from the Turkish site of Gobekli Tepe, in Anatolia. It is known as the "Vulture stone" (online) there are three "purses" across the top of the stone stela, and it includes a vulture (the astronaut theorists would say it suggests contact with ancient aliens!) it is really ancient, probably 12,000 years old. The middle image is from Mesoamerica, from the Olmec culture, it is more recent, ~1400 BC. It shows a man encircled by some kind of feathered snake. The one on the left is Assyrian, with an eagle-headed genie from ~800 BC (Source).
What are they?
Regular archaeologists interpret these purses as... purses. They are just that. Different types of handbags.
The Olmec one is held by a man, some kind of shaman wearing a jaguar mask. It is a ritual bag, a copal incense bag. The bag had a native name: copalxiquipilli or icpatoxin, and carried fragrant incense that was burned during religious ceremonies. Copal is the resin obtained from trees of the Burseraceae family. Not high-tech at all!
The Gobekli Tepe "purses" are specifically mentioned in a scientific paper (Banning, 2023), which I quote fully below: (highlight is mine)
"In connection with those roofs, I argued (Banning, 2011, pp. 629–631, 640) that the upper portion of pillar 43, with its depictions of enigmatic “box-like objects with handle-like attachments” (Schmidt, 2006, p. 39), may depict three of the pillar-buildings with vaulted or domed roofs, while small animal icons next to each may indicate the House, lineage, or clan associated with each building (Figure 3). Dietrich and Notroff (2017; Dietrich, 2021, p. 166; Notroff et al., 2017, p. 60) now appear to accept this hypothesis as a possibility:
On the uppermost part of Pillar 43, a row of three rectangular objects with cupola-like ‘arches’ on their tops can be seen… Each of these objects is accompanied by an animal added on the ‘arch’. The meaning of these images is hard to fathom, but they might represent the enclosures during their time of use, seen from the side. The rectangular part would represent the perimeter walls, while the cupolas may indicate roofs. As usually depictions of one animal species seem to dominate every enclosure…, it is an intriguing thought that buildings of different groups are depicted here with the emblematic animals of these groups added for recognition. (Dietrich & Notroff, 2016, pp. 25–26)"
Not purses, they are images of arches over buildings!
Finally the Assyrian purses are also ritual objets (Volt, 2026): "The Banduddu as Portable Abzu in Mesopotamian Apkallu Iconography ... The banduddu — the sealed vessel carried in the left hand of Apkallu figures across the Assyrian and Babylonian iconographic tradition — has been identified since Wiggermann (1992) as a bucket of consecrated liquid paired with the mullilu purification cone for ritual sprinkling." The cone used to sprinkle can be seen in the hand of the birdman. "Abzu", also called "Absu" is the primeval source of freshwater in the mythology of these people. Which makes sense, water in a desert enviornment is a source of life and purification.
Closing Comments
Validation of information, cross-checking facts and evaluating and analyzing information with a healthy skepticism is important. We are submerged with fake news on a daily basis, and few of us take the trouble to check it out. This purse-aliens example is just one case in a million.
So, it is easy to verify the facts and learn that the theory about ancient astronauts is based on wishful thinking, falsifying real archaeological evidence, and weaving tales that result in revenue from TV documentaries and books... Follow the money and you will understand the reason for these hoax stories.
Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall ©







No comments:
Post a Comment