Translate

Guide to Patagonia's Monsters & Mysterious beings

I have written a book on this intriguing subject which has just been published.
In this blog I will post excerpts and other interesting texts on this fascinating subject.

Austin Whittall


Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The "purse" and "ancient" astronauts


I really enjoy watching documentaries on TV, like those aired on Discovery or History Channel. Last night I smirked my way through one about "ancient astronauts", not because I believe in them (I don't), but because I was surprised at the farfetched conjectures put forward by the likes of Giorgio A. Tsoukalos and David Hatcher Childress. They weave fantastic stories and present them as if they were proven facts. Below I will dissect one of the things that they sold as if it was science, but has absolutely no scientific basis at all.


Some background


My first encounter with ancient artifacts attributed to extraterrestrials or alien contact happened in the 1970s. I was a gullible teenager and with my school mates we read all we could about UFOs, including a local (Argentine) magazine Cuarta Dimension (by another windbag: Fabio Zerpa). Among the books that I read, were two by Erich von Däniken (The Gold of the Gods, and Chariots of the Gods). Although I was fourteen years old, I was a bit skeptical about the idea that aliens had visited all these ancient people (from Peru, and Mesoamerica, to China, Egypt and the Middle East), imprinted the god myths in each culture, left absolutely no physical evidence of their presence, and vanished. Yet, the humans "replicated" or "reproduced" the artifacts these alien gods had displayed, creating depictions of winged creatures and birdmen (to show how these aliens flew), and objects that von Däniken interpreted as electric batteries, golden planes, men with astronaut helmets, computer chips, Nazca Lines, etc. I found it rather hard to believe they'd build pyramids in stone and other regular stone age stuff, but leave no high-tech artifacts stowed in some cache that would have been found by now, and cracked open using modern science (read Arthur C. Clarke's The Sentinel, which later led to some of the opening scenes of 2001: A Space Odyssey, which elaborate on how one would expect extraterrestrial intelligences would leave unequivocal evidence of their visit to Earth, and its Moon). Yes, in case you are wondering, I am an ardent fan of sci-fi, and Clarke, toghether with Asimov, Heinlein, and Bradbury were, and still are, some of my favorite authors of sci-fi.


Nowadays I do not believe in aliens visiting Earth, or alien contact, or artifacts hidden away by evil governments in warehouses like Area 51. I am open minded, and wonder, like Fermi did, when he asked back in 1950 "Where is everybody?." The maths (see Drake's equation) are impressive, and we must live in a Universe with several thousand advanced alien civilizations... but, we seem to all be stranded on our home planets, 50 years ago reached the most distant point yet from Earth, 1 light day, and that is nothing. The distance to the nearest star, Alpha Centauri is 1595 light days from us... or 80,000 years going at the speed of Voyager 1.


Birdmen


Yesterday's TV program was about winged birdlike creatures, said to represent the flying abilities of extraterrestrial visitors (wings = flight = UFOs flying). Of course, some winged guys had bird heads topping a human body, like the Egyptian gods Toth, with an ibis head or Horus with that of a hawk; but others had wings with human heads or bird heads and wings (Assyria) or no wings at all (Olmecs). So, what is the common denominator? Birdlike features? And we must surmise that this implies ET visitors?


But if this is the case, then, what do the other gods represent? For instance winged bulls from Assyria or the jackal headed Anubis, and Sobek the cow, or the feathered snake of the Mesoamericans? Mutant gods? Or, more likely, antropomorph depictions of the animals that were relevant to a particular culture. Birdmen could be just that, birds represented as humans, with no link to aliens.


The "purse"


An interesting fact mentioned in the program was an object called a purse, because that is what it looks like, a small box-like pouch hanging from a semicircular handle or strap. A common object, used by humans for tens of thousands of years (from hunter gatherers to modern women with Louis Vuitton purses) because it is practical and easy to make. But, in this instance, the alien "theorists" suggested that the object had some alien high tech in it, and was a symbol of extraterrestrial gods. These objects were shown in different stone engravings, from different parts of the world. Below you can see them:


Purses in ancient rock art. Copyright © 2025 by Austin Whittall

The image on the right, is from the Turkish site of Gobekli Tepe, in Anatolia. It is known as the "Vulture stone" (online) there are three "purses" across the top of the stone stela, and it includes a vulture (the astronaut theorists would say it suggests contact with ancient aliens!) it is really ancient, probably 12,000 years old. The middle image is from Mesoamerica, from the Olmec culture, it is more recent, ~1400 BC. It shows a man encircled by some kind of feathered snake. The one on the left is Assyrian, with an eagle-headed genie from ~800 BC (Source).


What are they?


Regular archaeologists interpret these purses as... purses. They are just that. Different types of handbags.


The Olmec one is held by a man, some kind of shaman wearing a jaguar mask. It is a ritual bag, a copal incense bag. The bag had a native name: copalxiquipilli or icpatoxin, and carried fragrant incense that was burned during religious ceremonies. Copal is the resin obtained from trees of the Burseraceae family. Not high-tech at all!


The Gobekli Tepe "purses" are specifically mentioned in a scientific paper (Banning, 2023), which I quote fully below: (highlight is mine)


"In connection with those roofs, I argued (Banning, 2011, pp. 629–631, 640) that the upper portion of pillar 43, with its depictions of enigmatic “box-like objects with handle-like attachments” (Schmidt, 2006, p. 39), may depict three of the pillar-buildings with vaulted or domed roofs, while small animal icons next to each may indicate the House, lineage, or clan associated with each building (Figure 3). Dietrich and Notroff (2017; Dietrich, 2021, p. 166; Notroff et al., 2017, p. 60) now appear to accept this hypothesis as a possibility:
On the uppermost part of Pillar 43, a row of three rectangular objects with cupola-like ‘arches’ on their tops can be seen… Each of these objects is accompanied by an animal added on the ‘arch’. The meaning of these images is hard to fathom, but they might represent the enclosures during their time of use, seen from the side. The rectangular part would represent the perimeter walls, while the cupolas may indicate roofs. As usually depictions of one animal species seem to dominate every enclosure…, it is an intriguing thought that buildings of different groups are depicted here with the emblematic animals of these groups added for recognition. (Dietrich & Notroff, 2016, pp. 25–26)
"


Not purses, they are images of arches over buildings!


Finally the Assyrian purses are also ritual objets (Volt, 2026): "The Banduddu as Portable Abzu in Mesopotamian Apkallu Iconography ... The banduddu — the sealed vessel carried in the left hand of Apkallu figures across the Assyrian and Babylonian iconographic tradition — has been identified since Wiggermann (1992) as a bucket of consecrated liquid paired with the mullilu purification cone for ritual sprinkling." The cone used to sprinkle can be seen in the hand of the birdman. "Abzu", also called "Absu" is the primeval source of freshwater in the mythology of these people. Which makes sense, water in a desert enviornment is a source of life and purification.


Closing Comments


pseudoscience warning

Validation of information, cross-checking facts and evaluating and analyzing information with a healthy skepticism is important. We are submerged with fake news on a daily basis, and few of us take the trouble to check it out. This purse-aliens example is just one case in a million.


So, it is easy to verify the facts and learn that the theory about ancient astronauts is based on wishful thinking, falsifying real archaeological evidence, and weaving tales that result in revenue from TV documentaries and books... Follow the money and you will understand the reason for these hoax stories.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

The shape of Denisovan skulls... and their relationship with other hominins


A paper published in Nature on October 21st, 2026 analyzed the proteins of the Denisovan Xujiayao specimens from China. They found several (18) proteins that are exclusive to these people. One in particular is the COL1A2-996 R>K mutation (Arginine to Lysine replacement in the position 996), that is not seen in any modern humans or Neanderthals. This is a mutation that signals that the Xujiayao people were Denisovans.


The authors, knowing that these remains are Denisovans, use their morphology (shape) to compare it with those of erectus, modern humans, and Neanderthals. We must remember that we have not, until now, managed to identify Denisovan skulls, so this paper gives us detailed information on the features of Denisovans. Which, according to the paper are distinct: "...traits reminiscent of Homo erectus (such as a thick cranial vault) and those characteristic of modern humans (for example, a strongly arched temporal squama). They also share features with late Neanderthals, such as the structure of the temporal labyrinth and the presence of a suprainiac fossa. Notably, Denisovans are distinctive, with a low cranial profile with near-parallel lateral walls, a massive supraorbital torus, a flat zygomaxillary region and weak prognathism."


This is the article (fully accessible): Xing, S., Wu, Z., Shao, Q. et al. The proteome of Middle Pleistocene Xujiayao and common Denisovan morphology. Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11132-z


The proteic signature


The COL1A2-996K protein signature is common to all Denisovan specimens, not only the Xujiayao ones, it is also found in the Xiaje, Penghu 1, Harbin, and Denisova 3 remains. It is different from the variant carried by humans and Neanderthals.


The authors, having defined that Xujiayao was a Denisovan, used its skull to define the skull features of Denisovans. And they found them to have a blend of different hominin characteristics.


Erectus. Which I find quite reasonable, considering that Denisovans and erectus admixed: "Xujiayao hominins exhibit erectus-like features, including a low and wide neurocranium, a thick cranial vault (bregma, 7.7 mm; parietal tubercle, 12.0 mm), a weak parasagittal depression (not in Harbin), a short (large in Harbin) and inwardly inflexed mastoid process, an asymmetrical mandibular notch (with the crest attached to the lateral third of the condyle), an open mandibular foramen, and M2, M3 and M3 complete main cusps (where the superscript and subscript values denote upper jaw and lower jaw molars, respectively)."


Notice the differences found in the Harbin specimen.


They also have some elements shared with the Homo Heidelbergensis, Neanderthals and modern humans: "a strongly arched temporal squama, a moderately developed suprameatal spine and a more symmetrical crown outline with a longer buccal cusp compared with the lingual cusp, reduced buccal contour protrusion and a simplified occlusal surface lacking the bifurcated buccal essential crest in P3 (upper third premolar)."


But they also have their own, specific differences when compared to humans and erectus: "These include a low cranial profile with near-parallel or slightly convergent lateral walls, a nearly vertical occipital plane (with a larger occipital angle than in H. erectus; but a non-rounded occipital bone, a non-coronally oriented tympanic plate deflected to the petrosal (also present in late Neanderthals), a weak angular torus and a moderate linear occipital torus (commonly moderate in late Neanderthals but weak in Harbin). In these features, the Xujiayao Denisovan is generally comparable to African and European H. heidelbergensis and early Neanderthals."


Similarity with Heidelbergensis is expected. The Homo heidelbergensis is believed to be the common ancestor of the Neanderthals-Denisovans and modern humans. Out of Africa theory has them evolving in Africa and somehow moving to Europe. I believe that they are Eurasians.


The paper also repports something that is quite unusual among "Homo" fossils, it is the shape of the teeth: "The Denisovan mandibles represented by those from Xujiayao, Xiahe and Penghu display a distinct depression within the mandibular planum triangulare, a feature that is uncommon in other members of the genus Homo."


The origin of Neanderthals


This Chinese authored paper also notices that Neanderthals have changed over time, and attribute the different jaw, and skull shapes to two possible causes: "Molecular studies revealed that the late Neanderthal’s Y chromosome and mitochondrial DNA possibly were replaced with the introgression of the modern human population in the early Late Pleistocene. Alternatively, late Neanderthals may have originated from a unilineal modern human expansion into Europe 400–250 ka, accompanied by substantial introgression of local archaic genes into the autosomes." It goes on to point out that the Denisovan fossils are closer to the ancestral root (similar to "early" Neanderthals and H. heidelbergensis) and attribute the different morphology of the more recent Neanderthals to admixture with humans: "these findings suggest that modern humans or local archaic hominin introgression not only altered the genetic structure but also influenced the cranial morphology of later Neanderthals. This might explain the substantial morphological divergence between Denisovans and late Neanderthals."


I have the feeling that as Chinese scholars, prompted by their sinocentric, and nationalist pride advance in their research on Denisovans, we will be surprised by new discoveries that will help us understand the role played by these mysterious people, and how they interacted with other hominins. This could shake up the smug orthodoxy of the Out Of Africa theory with a stronger Eurasian element.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Xalnene ash footprints in Mexico: 40,000 years old


Several years ago, I posted about some footprints reportedly 35,000 to 40,000 years old, close to Lake Valsequillo in Mexico. The authors of one of the papers mentioned in that post insisted with those extremely old dates (far older than what is accepted by mainstream scholars) in a second paper on the subject, with more evidence. Let's take a look at this second paper published twenty years ago.


The second research paper is the following (notice its revealing title):
  — Silvia González, David Huddart, Matthew R. Bennett, Alberto González-Huesca, (2006) Human footprints in Central Mexico older than 40,000 years, Quaternary Science Reviews, Vol 25, 3–4, pp 201-222, ISSN 0277-3791, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quascirev.2005.10.004.


This paper's abstract states that:


"... new evidence is presented in this paper, in the form of human footprints preserved in indurated volcanic ash, to suggest that Central Mexico was inhabited as early as over 40 ka BP.
Human and animal footprints have been found within the upper bedding surfaces of the Xalnene volcanic ash layer that outcrops in the Valsequillo Basin, south of Puebla, Mexico. This ash layer was produced by a subaqueous monogenetic volcano erupting within a palaeo-lake, dammed by lava within the Valsequillo Basin during the Pleistocene. The footprints were formed during low stands in lake level along the former shorelines and indicate the presence of humans, deer, canids, big felids, and probably camels and bovids. The footprints were buried by ash and lake sediments as lake levels rose and transgressed across the site. The ash has been dated to at least 40 ka BP by OSL dating of incorporated, baked lake sediments.
"


The human footprints are preserved in volcanic ash, which can be dated. The ash fell on the coast of a shallow lake that existed in the Valsequillo Basin (close to Puebla, Mexico — See location in Google maps. A modern dam has flooded the area).


The authors also point out that "The Valsequillo Basin is dotted with other small abandoned quarries, and in several of them it is possible to recognize more human and animal footprints in what we call the ‘Xalnene ash footprint layer’. In this paper we report the footprints found in just one small quarry close to Cerro Toluquilla... The other sites remain to be recorded and studied."


Finding human prints in Mexico dated to 40,000 years ago, predating the last Glacial Maximum is suggestive. It ties in neatly with other ancient sites of a similar age, and hint at a very early date for the peopling of America.


A paper by Morse et al. published in 2010 is highly critical of these prints, and concluded that "Using an objective statistically based methodology developed here, these controversial marks are re-examined and found to be of questionable origin, as they are inconsistent with a suite of other, known human and hominin prints. Consequently, we argue that they should be removed as evidence in the ongoing controversy surrounding the colonization of the Americas."


They compare Australopith and modern human prints with these Mexican ones (see their Fig. 1) and find that they have a "greater breadth [and] atypical distribution of footprint depths" than those. In my opinion this could be due to the fact that they belong to non-sapiens humans, for instance Denisovans (taller and sturdier than we are), which could have made different imprints.


Yet another paper disputes the age of the prints (Feinberg et al., 2009) arguing that the ash is much older: 1.3 million years old, and that "Human origin of the marks is unlikely given early Homo erectus distribution and Americas peopling evidence. Marks likely result from quarrying activities, later enhanced by weathering and erosion."


The way the authors discard a possible non-sapiens (i.e. erectus) origin for these prints based on the fact that no erectus remains have been found in the Americas and that "peopling evidence" (i.e. current understanding) places the event at not more than 25,000 years ago. They conclude as follows:


"The evidence from paleomagnetic analysis and 40Ar/39Ar dating show that the Xalnene Tuff is not 40 ka old. Instead, our data show unam-biguously that the Xalnene Tuff is 1.3 Ma. If the marks identified by González et al. (2006a) were of human origin, then they would probably belong to early Homo erectus (Antón and Swisher, 2004). This is unlikely, based on the known geographic distribution of these early hominids (Antón and Swisher, 2004) and the genetic and archaeological evidence for the peopling of the Americas (Goebel et al., 2008). The marks observed by González et al. (2006a) were found in a stone quarry and are more likely to represent marks left behind from this quarry-ing, which were later enhanced by weathering and erosion."


A final research paper argues that the age is ~40,000 years, and that the prints represent an early human site in America (Goguitchaichvili et al., 2009).


So, there are different dates (1.3 million to 40 ky) and conflicting points of view on the origin of the prints (ancient hominins or modern quarry workers). I tend to belive they are ancient, and maybe even 1.3 million years old.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Sunday, November 8, 2026

On a near miss extinction of hominins


A paper by Wangjie Hu published in 2023 in the prestigious journal Science (Genomic inference of a severe human bottleneck during the Early to Middle Pleistocene transition. Science 381, 979-984 (2023). DOI:10.1126/science.abq7487), reported that our ancestors had a very close shave with extinction.


The article, which of course assumes that the Out Of Africa (OOA) migration is valid, found that non-Africans and Africans split long before the actual migration OOA took place: "African and non-African divergence occurred much earlier than the out-of-Africa dispersal,"


The population leading to modern non-Africans began its decline around 368,000 years ago —368 ky (the range, however is very wide: 176 to 756 kya). This wide range is enough to cover the split that led to the ancestors of Neanderthals and Denisovans.


The bottleneck


The study involved genetics, and infered population sizes, and found a "severe bottleneck" in "each of the 10 African populations" that they sampled, but surprisingly, it was absent in all of the "40 non-African populations." Why would the non-Africans, who are supposed to have split from Africans not carry the signs of the near extinction event? (a simple explanation would be that non-Africans had evolved separately in Eurasia and were not affected by the event, which struck ancient Africans, leaving a direct mark on contemporary Africans. They did not detect direct signals of a near extinction event in non-Africans.


But, the OOA theory can't be questioned, so the authors ran different simulations to find out what was going on. They concluded that the OOA event obscured the signal in non-Africans!!


The paper proposed three different population bottleneck scenarios (I, II, and III). The first (I) agreed with their model of how modern African populations evolved after going through a masive ancient bottleneck. The second secnario (II) was one under which the non-African populations did not go through any bottleneck and it agreed with their model. So then they devised a third scenario (III) which impacted non-Africans with an ancient bottleneck.


But III didn't appear as viable in their model: "However, no ancient severe bottleneck was detected in bottleneck III simulations." So, instead of assuming there was no bottleneck, they concluded that this failure of their model was due to the OOA effect: "[it] indicates that the out-of-Africa dispersal hinders the chance of discovering the ancient severe bottleneck. Furthermore, the ancient severe bottleneck was found to cause a discrepancy in the estimation of the population size between the bottleneck III model and the inferred population size history after the bottleneck was relieved, which suggests a hidden effect of the ancient severe bottleneck on non-African populations." In my opinion, this sounds like they are trying to save the OOA model at all costs.


Their argument was that the OOA event reduced the lineages outside of Africa and erased the genetic evidence of the bottleneck. But, inside Africa, these survived, so all African lineages showed the evidence of the bottleneck (seems like circular reasoning to me!)


With this axiom in mind they used a program called FitCoal and (their explanation seems to be a polite way of saying "we made the data fit our model, cooking the numbers"): "performed an extended FitCoal analysis. To eliminate noise effects resulting from problems such as sequencing or overfitting errors on the inference of population size history, we used the FitCoal-inferred recent population size history as a starting point for size estimation of an ancient population. With this modification, all 19 non-African populations in 1000GP were found to have gone through the severe bottleneck with approximately 1450 individuals between 921 and 785 kyr BP. This result is consistent with that obtained with African populations."


They seem to have shoehorned it into the model, like the bed of Procustes (a Greek fable, where a bandit named Procustes invited people to sleep in his bed, and if they were too long, he cut off their legs, and if they were too short, he'd stretch them on a rack).


Anyway, based on their analysis they concluded that a near extinction event took place 930,000 years ago, and lasted for 117,000 years, which wiped out 98.7% of all humans living at that time. The date makes it take place inside Africa, and it affected the ancestors of thosw who would later evolve into modern humans, Neanderthals and Denisovans. It wiped out genetic diversity ("increas[ing] the inbreeding level of our ancestors, thus contributing to the 65.85% loss in present-day human genetic diversity".)


This near miss was triggered by the ice age in an episode known as the "“0.9 Ma event” (Ma, million years ago)" at that time the ice sheets and sea level variations led to drought, which impacted on vegetation and wildlife.


The dramatic drop in hominin population is the explanation -say the authors- for the lack of fossils during this period (950-650 ky ago) in Africa. However, outside of Africa, Homo erectus thrived, and the Atapuerca hominins also survived. Why? The paper does not provide answers. The authors also suggest that the fusion of chromosome 2 in humans took place during this period leading to the ancestor of Denisovans, Neanderthals, and modern humans.


There was a quick rebound after the near extinction event: "a rapid population recovery was detected in all 10 African populations with a 20-fold increase in size around 813 kyr BP." Tha authors attribute this to the discovery of fire and benign climate.


Closing Comments


Are we overdoing it with genetics and ancient humans? This is like trying to wring blood from a stone.


I wonder if we can extrapolate back in time over a vast period of nearly 950,000 years, and comparing modern human genes of non-Africans and Africans come up with a theory suggesting that a massive near-extinction event took place, which left only 13 out of every 1,000 acient hominins (in Africa) alive, but left those in Eurasia untouched.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Saturday, November 7, 2026

Coxcatlán Cave, Mexico: 33 ky human presence


I am just back from a short but well deserved vacation with our children, their partners, and our grandchildren. Sharing quality time with the family is, in my opinion, one of the best things one can do. It is a pity that life is so short!


But, getting down to the subject of my blog, I'd like to share a paper🞿 published in 2021, that reported ancient pre-Clovis dates of more than 30,000 years ago, for a site in Mexico.


🞿 This is the paper: Somerville AD, Casar I, Arroyo-Cabrales J. New AMS Radiocarbon Ages from the Preceramic Levels of Coxcatlan Cave, Puebla, Mexico: A Pleistocene Occupation of the Tehuacan Valley? Latin American Antiquity. 2021;32(3):612-626. doi:10.1017/laq.2021.26



The site is known as Coxcatlan Cave, and it is located in the state of Puebla, in Mexico (Google map), roughly 320 km (200 mi.) southeast of Mexico City. It was discovered in the 1960s by the American archaeologist Richard Stockton MacNeish (1918-2001). MacNeish found remains of a plant known as teosintle (or teocintle), Zea perennis, a wild variety that is an ancient ancestor of maize, that later domesticated, producing modern maize. These remains were between 7,000 and 8,700 years old.


The cave is set in Tehuacan Valley, and was occupied by humans over a period spanning more than ten thousand years. The most recent groups, in the cave's upper sediment layers, were the nomads who gathered teosinte, that later became farmers.


But, what is really interesting is found in the oldest, deepest layers of the cave. These were analyzed by Somerville et al and dated using accelerated mass spectrometry radiocarbon dating techniques. They were expecting them to be not older than 12,000 yers BP, but instead, they were much older: "[the] bones from the Ajuereado phase zones at the base of the cave yielded surprisingly old ages that range from 33,448 to 28,279 cal BP, a time prior to the Last Glacial Maximum. Because these early ages are many thousands of years older than current models estimate for the peopling of the Americas, they require reassessments of the artifacts and ecofacts excavated from these early zones." A conflict with the orthodox viewpoint of a recent peopling of America!


The oldest layers are known as the Ajuereado level, which has two phases, "Early" and "Later", each of them is composed of different "Zones".


The oldest zone of the Early phase contained crude stone tools: "Minimally worked blades, end-scrapers, and choppers are present" as well as "Pleistocene fauna" while the more recent 10,000 to 14,500 year-old layers of the "Later" Ajuereado phase had more advanced stone tools ("bifacial projectile points; that is, Lerma and Abasolo points" and modern animal remains.


Old Dates


The authors measured dates of bones from the Early Ajuereado phase zones. And found them to be "much older than anticipated", they were 33,228 to 28,279 cal BP years old.


The Early phase produced a lot of lepus (rabbit species, like the jackrabbit) bones, that had been cracked open by humans, they show cut marks, and had also been cooked: There was charcoal and also "crude" stone tools and flakes.


The tools were manmade, as they were composed of flint, which is not found in the rocks of the cave, implying that the stone was brought to the cave from an external quarry. The authors point out that " ... a material external to the cave, makes it difficult to dismiss them as cultural artifacts."


This is at odds with the accepted dates for the peopling of America, but the tools, bones, and fire clearly indicate an early date for the presence of humans at Coxcatlán:


"Because many of the stone tools associated with these early levels are only minimally worked and the antiquity of the ages places these stratigraphic layers many thousands of years before traditional hypotheses posit the arrival of humans in North America, the identity of these objects as tools remains questionable. Nevertheless, the observations that the faunal remains appear to have been processed by humans, that the stone tools are made from flint, and that several stone tools exhibit retouching provide support for the notion of a pre-LGM occupation of Coxcatlan Cave during the Early Ajuereado phase. The radiocarbon ages produced from this study mandate a careful reconsideration of the materials recovered from these zones, including a close inspection of the chipped-stone tools and an analysis of faunal material to document breakage patterns, cut marks, and thermal alterations. The results of this study and those of future reanalyses have important implications for our understanding of several important issues in the archaeology of the New World, including the peopling of the Americas, the timing and causes of the megafaunal extinctions, and the origins of agriculture."


In support for an early presence of humans in this region, the paper cites Mirambell, Lorena, 1994 Los primeros pobladores del actual territorio mexicano. In Historia antigua de México, edited by Manzanilla, Linda R. and Luján, Leonardo López, pp. 177–208. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia, Mexico City. Mirambell mentioned the site at Rancho La Amapola with dates ranging from 45,000 to 25,000 cal. radiocarbon years BP, which produced "a chipped-stone discoidal scraper and Pleistocene faunal bones, including a broken and utilized horse tibia."


Comments


This is an extremely old date. At least 15,000 years older than any site in America. In my opinion, the crude tools of the Early Ajuereado phase are evidence of a more primitive group of humans in the area. These humans mastered fire, made stone tools, and coexisted with the megafauna. The Later Ajuereado phase is 10,000 to 14,500 years old, and represents a more sophisticated group of humans (different tools).


Could this indicate an original group of humans (Denisovans or Neanderthals?) in America 30,000 years ago, replaced by a more recent wave of migrants (Homo sapiens) some 15,000 years ago?



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Thursday, October 22, 2026

Reich and a 300 kya modern human expansion into Africa and Europe from the Levant


David Reich updated his preprint on October 13, 2026. It has a his take on the Origin of Neanderthals, and Modern Humans, a revision of the Out of Africa theory, and the dispersal of the first humans into Europe and Africa, and admixture with archaics in both places. (See it online: Hypothesis: A modern human range expansion ∼300,000 years ago had a critical role in Neandertal origins, David Reich, bioRxiv 2026.03.11.711219; doi: https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.03.11.711219)


The following map shows the outline of Reich's hypothesis. Fig. 1. in his preprint.


300 kya dispersal of humans
Original image caption reads: A bicontinental range expansion ∼300 ka.
(a) I start with a previously proposed model for the relationship of Neandertals, Denisovans, and modern Africans in which an early modern lineage contributed mtDNA and Y chromosomes to Neandertals and ∼3-7% of the rest of the genome3. I graft onto it the deep substructure detected in people today, inferred in one study to contribute ∼80% of the ancestry of present-day Africans11, and inferred in several studies to have ended around ∼300 ka7,11,12. At bottom are estimates of divergences and population splits: range of estimated dates for the autosomes, and 95% confidence intervals for mtDNA and Y1. (Not shown: <50 ka gene flow from Neandertals and Denisovans into non-Africans, and superarchaic gene flow to Denisovans.)
(b) Schematic of what the range expansion might have looked like after ∼300 ka, with an early modern human lineage in northeast Africa or the Near East expanding both into Europe and Africa and mixing with local archaic populations; ancestry within these regions would then have homogenized due to admixture among neighbors; the red-to-blue shading indicates mixing. The European archaic range is drawn based on an estimate of the later Neandertal range
. Source

Brief Summary


Reich seems to be going alone with this article. There are no other authors. It isn't revert decades of entrenched "Out Of Africanism", but the time is ripe, and this is a first step in the right direction.


This paper by David Reich upturns the classic Out Of Africa (OOA) theory. He suggests that modern humans originated around 300,000 years ago. He does not specifically pinpoint their place of origin, but, although he includes North Africa and a corridor along the Nile to Ethiopia, he has added a Eurasian range that spans the Levant, Mesopotamia, and the Caucasus.


Reich the "expansion" of an "early modern human lineage in northeast Africa or the Near East expanding both into Europe and Africa and mixing with local archaic populations; ancestry within these regions" Highlight is mine. I would imagine a group descended from Eurasian Homo erectus evolving in the Levant and then migrating into Africa.


These modern humans then moved into Europe, where they admixed with European archaics (like the Homo antecessor), originating the Neanderthals, and further south into Subsaharan Africa where they met, and mated with very ancient Archaic Africans (they had split from the other branch 1.5 million years ago).


This does away with the current story: Homo heidelbergensis was the ancestor of modern humans, Neanderthals and Denisovans. It lived in Western Eurasia and Africa. Then, 300 ky in North Africa it evolved into H. sapiens, there was a first, failed OOA migration ~150 ky ago into the Levant that introgressed human genes into Neanderthals there. Finally, 60 ky ago, modern humans left Africa and replaced, in one single burst, all other humans in the Old World.


Neanderthals descend from modern humans


Reich's take explains why Neanderthals and Denisovans are so similar, from a genetic point of view, yet differ in their mtDNA and Y-chromosome (Neanderthal's are closer to ours). The mtDNA is transmitted by mothers to children (matrilineal), and chromosome Y is patrilineal (father to son), so here we have a theory that basically states that Neanderthals descended from modern humans.


Reich notes that ancient "Neanderthals harbor 3-7% admixturefrom an early modern human lineage ∼300-200 ka"


Modern Humans from the Levant entered Europe and mated with the Archaics that lived there, the blend led to the appearance of Neanderthals, which retained 93% to 97% of the original genes (mainly autosomal), but inherited modern human mtDNA and Y-chromosomes.


Reich then proposes four different scenarios to explain how modern humans passed their uniparental markers on and replaced those in the archaic population.


Into Africa and mix with African Archaics


Another band of these Levantine modern humans moved south into deep Africa and mated with extremely ancient archaic Africans.


Here the mix was very different to the one that took place in Europe. The hybrid population that resulted from the admixture retained 80% modern human and 20% African archaic alleles.


These African Archaics come from a lineage that split 1.5 million years ago from the one that led to the modern humans in North Africa and SW Asia, they evolved separately for 1.2 million years until they encountered these modern humans 300 ky ago. Reich does not say who they were. Were they Homo ergaster or the primitive Homo naledi. Archaic admixture is something that easily explains the "diversity" of Africans vs. non-Africans.


Reich points out that the archaic Europeans were more similar to modern humans: "In Europe, the expansion of this population [modern humans] led to large-scale incorporation of local archaic genes because barriers to producing viable offspring were few, giving rise to Neandertals who ultimately harbored 3-7% ancestry from the expanding early modern human lineage."


But the archaics in Africa were really different: "In Africa, the mixture was with a more divergent lineage, which meant that there was less permeability of the expanding population to admixture with the local archaic group. Thus, the final population which became our own ancestors had a much higher proportion of ancestry from the expanding early modern human lineage."


The Levallois tools


Reich refloats a suggestion first published twentynine years ago by Rob Foley and Marta Lahr in 1997, the "Mode 3 hypothesis". They noticed that around 300,000 years ago a different stone knapping technique appeared, called Levallois. It involves more brainpower because the toolmaker has to work a stone core, in what are known as "prepared core" techniques, shaping the core to prepare it for the flakes that will later be struck from it. This "planning" and foreknowledge of the outcome requires a higher level of cognition than the older Acheulean (Mode 2) or primitive Oldowan (Mode 1) stone knapping.


Reich believes that "Levallois points" are the archaeological proof for his hypothesis. The timing is closer to 400,000 years ago: "...The genetically inferred expansion follows the time when a tool production technique (Levallois points) based on prepared stone cores spread across a wide area of Africa where it was used by early modern humans (known there as the Middle Stone Age and starting by at least 400 ka), and to the Middle East and Europe where it was used by Neandertals (known there as the Middle Paleolithic, starting by at least 480-300 ka)."


It links Neanderthals and Africans during the Middle Stone Age. Notice that the European tools are older than the African ones. Reich adds that the Denisovans in the Far East did not use this technique at such an eraly date: "There is evidence that these technologies were used much less intensively or not at all in East Asia where the closest cousins of early modern humans and Neandertals were Denisovans. In China, the sole strong claim of Levallois in the Middle Paleolithic is at the site of Guanyindong Cave dating to ∼170-80 ka, but this is not a confident inference as another study refutes this interpretation. Levallois has been documented in the Altai Mountains, but this region was proximate to West Eurasia and the technology could have spread from there through contact with Neandertal populations which are well-documented in the Altai. Similarly, evidence of Levallois in India ∼250-200 ka could have been spread by modern human populations from the Near East"


So he also suggests that modern humans were present in India and the Near East, 250,000 to 200,000 years ago. This is far older than the 60 ky suggested by the current version of the Out Of Africa Theory.


PRDM9 gene


Reich also mentions some genetic proof, the PRDM9 gene (that is a link to my post on it). Reich interprets the three main variants of this gene originated over 300 ky ago, and that one of them not found in Denisovans or Neanderthals but present in modern humans, came from archaic Africans. The second lineage is found in Denisovans and Neanderthals but not in modern Africans and is a signal of the archaic Eurasians. The third one "—showing evidence of activity of the “PRDM9-A” allele, which Denisovans lack— is the expanding early modern human lineage represented in admixed form in Neandertals and modern humans living today, but not in Denisovans: a successful early modern human population."


Comments


This is a shift in the simple OOA theory. It implies that modern humans (very likely from the Levant) expanded into Europe, met the archaic population living there, and gradually, as it moved across the continent admixed. The Neanderthal (and Denisovans) that resulted from this blend, "retain[ed] early modern human mtDNA and Y chromosomes while having most of the rest of their genome replaced by archaic genes."


Another group of modern humans from the Levant moved into Africa where our ancestors, "the ancestors of living humans" rose as the outcome of admixture with very ancient archaic hominins lifing in Africa.


It sounds compelling. But, there is only so much that can be inferred from modern genes (the samples taken from modern humans), and old, ancient DNA is lacking in Africa. We have very few samples from Eurasia, and none from archaics. So, further research is needed, and more ancient DNA from Africa, as well as Southern and Southeastern Asia.


But, there are some unanswered questions. Why would such an advanced group of early modern humans, living in a wide territorial range (Morocco to Iran, to Georgia, Iraq, Jordania, Israel, Egypt, etc) die out completely and be replaced by a more recent group trekking out of deep Africa 60,000 years ago? Who were the superarchaics living in Africa 300 kya? Where did Reich get the evidence for this Soutwestern Eurasian territorial distribution? How did the early modern humans originate? (from erectus?). The role of Denisovans (we still don't know much about them)?


Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Sunday, October 18, 2026

Bulrush based societies have existed for over 30 kya


In my recent series of posts about the redheaded "giants" of Lovelock Cave, Nevada, I mentioned that they had developed a lifestyle adapted to living by and on the lakes (dwindling after the Last Ice Age) of the Great Basin Region. They thrived on bulrushes. The Paiute people, who exterminated the last bands of these people called them Si-te-cah or tule-eaters, after the bulrushes known as tule, that they exploited in their lacustrine and fluvial territory.


Early humans, who lived a hunter-gatherer life, included bulrushes as part of their diet. They ate the tender shoots, and cooked, baked, and ground the roots or rhizomes of these plants into flour. They also used the stems to make mats, baskets, huts, and boats. The Si-te-cah people lived on floating rush islands, in a similar way to the Uro people of Lake Titicaca in Peru and Bolivia.


bulrush global distribution
Fig 1. Global distribution of Typha species (bulrushes). Source

The map above shows the global distribution of the cattail family, the Typhaceae. They are found in wetlands across the world, from New Zealand to Canada. Their name Typha comes from the Greek word for marsh. They can survive in wet, hot, cold, and continental climates, even in freezing icy conditions.


An ancient lifestyle


The oldest proof of bulrush exploitation has been found at Upper Paleolithic sites in Europe, dating back 30,000 years (30 ky).


In a research paper, Revedin et al., 2010, (Thirty thousand-year-old evidence of plant food processing, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 107 (44) 18815-18819, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1006993107) discuss the discovery of grinding implements used at European sites:


Bilancino II (Italy), Kostenki 16–Uglyanka (Russia), and Pavlov VI (Czech Republic). They ground different kinds of plants, and these have been identified: Bilancino II is 28 ky old, and the "highly specialized tool types were probably used for the separation of the vegetable fibers from cattail (Typha) leaves... Considering the size distribution of the morphotype e grains, the mode of the measured values is closer to that calculated for Typha angustifolia (narrow leaf cattail) than to that of Typha latifolia (broadleaf cattail) ."


Kostenki site is roughly 31 ky old, moonworts were processed with stone mortars. At Pavlov VI (29 ky old), moonworts and cattails were pounded into flour.


The authors point out that "the practices that we can reconstruct demonstrate knowledge in the Gravettian populations of Europe of the starch-rich portions of edible plants, combined with the ability to transform them to produce a complex dried product (flour). This would have allowed them greater independence from environmental and seasonal fluctuations." Did other hominins adopt this lifestyle?


Neanderthals and rushes


A paper (Hardy BL, Moncel MH. Neanderthal use of fish, mammals, birds, starchy plants and wood 125-250,000 years ago. PLoS One. 2011;6(8):e23768. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0023768. Epub 2011 Aug 24. PMID: 21887315; PMCID: PMC3161061.) reported that Neanderthals living in the Rhone Valley in France 250,000 to 125,000 years ago, processed the starchy roots of plants using stone tools. Were they bulrushes? We don't know for certain. But this site, at Payre shows they were well equipped to obtain starchy carbohydrates from local plants.


China 10,000 years BP


More recently, rushes were used as food in China as reported by Zhang et al., 2020 (Typha as a wetland food resource: evidence from the Tianluoshan site, Lower Yangtze Region, China some 10,000 years ago). The article discusses the people who inhabited the wetlands along the Yangtze River in China. They found "extremely high percentages of Typha" (bulrush) pollen in their fossilized feces. This site is more recent than those discussed in the previous section, and belong to Neolithic humans. This is close to the birth of agriculture ~10 kya, and these people were also exploiting rice. They note that "The coexistence of Typha and rice also gives clues about the environmental background and agricultural management of early rice paddy, with respect to eutrophication, weeding and inundation." Hinting at agricultural practices regarding the bulrushes.


Australian Aboriginals (past 60 ky)


Ken Macintyre and Barb Dobson, 2023 report that the original people of Australia added Typha rhizomes to their diet. They processed these roots into edible flour, and baked bread from it. They also managed the bulrush growth by burning the dry stands during the dry season. This "muck" burning returned nutrients to the soil and promoted the growth of larger rhizomes which had fewer "hairs" and were thicker.


This was a very ancient practice, and Macintyre & Dobson suggest that "We would assume given the antiquity of Australian Aboriginal culture that if such archaeological research were to be systematically conducted on grinding materials from southwestern Australia that the results could well predate these European findings", in other words, they would be older than the 30,000 years reported by Revedin et al.


North American Natives


In my Lovelock series I mentioned the Umatilla people as also being named "tule-eaters" by the Paiute. They lived in Oregon, and although they were not lacustrine like the Tulares or the Lake Tule (Modocs), they also exploited the tule bulrushes. The picture below, by Lee Moorhouse (1850-1926) is captioned "Indian camps on Columbia river, opposite Umatilla c.1900-1910 and depicts "a tipi made of boards, poles, mats and cloth is located on the flat, rocky shore of the Columbia River. Nearby are two horses." The tipi is made of bulrush reed mats. They were light, strong, and provided insulation. They swelled up when wet, provided a waterproof roof.


Umatilla Tipi

Below is Lake Tule, where the Modocs lived (Source), by the way, the scenery is magnificent.


Lake Tule California

Many natives lived in reed huts and we have a drawing by F. Wikersheim described as Californie, rancheria des Indiens d' hocks sur les bords de la rivière de la plume. (cluster of huts of the Hocks Indians. California, on the banks of Feather River, near Yuba city, drawn c.1850 during the California Gold Rush.


rancheria Feather River 1850s

In this same area (close to Yuba City), we have another drawing of a native encampment (Robert B. Honeyman, Jr. Collection, c.1850s). Both images correspond to the Sacramento River valley.


Yuba city rancheria

The Yokut people of Lake Tulare and the San Joaquin River basin also built tule huts. The following image, from Contributions to North American ethnology. Vol. III, by John W. Powell, 1873, p. 231 shows "Yo'-kuts Tule Lodges":


Yokuts tule lodges, 1873

Powell describes their lifestyle: "In the mountain streams which empty into Tulare Lake they catch lake trout, chubs, and suckers... On Tulare Lake they construct very rude, frail punts or mere troughs of tule, about ten feet long, in which they cruise timidly about near the shore... Their range of food is extensive. Around the lake they cut and dry the seed-stalks of a kind of flag (Typha) which has a head something like a teasel, thresh out the seed and make flour of if; also wild rye and wild sunflower seed...."


The Paiute once again try to exterminate the tule-eaters


Interestingly, Powell also records that the Yokuts were under attack by "the more powerful and warlike Paiuti of Nevada" who managed to bypass the Sierra Nevada through the "the passes which occur at the northern and southern points of junction between the Sierra and the Coast Range... allowed ... the Paiuti... to swarm in toward the rich and tempting plains of California, dispossessing the feebler peoples who were there before them. Living as they do at the lower end of the great basin, the Yokuts received the brunt of the Paiuti attacks. So severe were the latter that the Yokuts, as a geographically solid body of allied tribes, were cut in two in one place and nearly in another. Their habitat stretched originally from the Fresno River to Fort Tejon; but the Paiuti tribes, swarming through Ta-hi’-cha-pa, Tejon, and Walker's Passes, seized and occupied Kern River, White River, Posa Creek, and Kern Lake, thus completely severing the Yokuts nation, and leaving an isolated fragment of it at Fort Tejon, in a nook of the mountains. Doubtless they would eventually have seized all the streams emptying into Tulare Lake, but they seem to have become enervated by the malaria, and reduced to the same condition of sluggishness as the people whom they displaced." Once again, as with the redheaded giants, the Paiute were aggressive and fought against the peaceful tule-eaters of California.


Ancient links between humans and wetlands


The oldest human footprints in America were discovered in White Sands, New Mexico. Now a barren gypsum dune field, 24,000 years ago it was a freshwater lake (Lake Otero) that covered an area of 4,150 km2 (1,600 sq. mi.). This was a suitable habitat. Wetlands provide fish, water fowl, and attract large animals (drink, and vegetation for foraging). Maybe these very ancient paleoindians also used the tule rushes of the lake (the basin is now known as Tularosa (from "tule" and "rosa" = "pink" in Spanish).


Comments


Rushes are a valuable resource, providing fiber for thatching, mats, footwear, canoes, huts, and baskets. Tender shoots, starchy roots, and the food-rich wetland enviornment surely attracted archaic hominins to this kind of habitat.


In an era that preceded agriculture, controlled burns and a stable settlement by a wetland ensured a year-round food supply. It is very likely that hominins exploited these resources in Eurasia, and after entering America did so in North America. The map at the beginning of this post shows that bulrushes were widely distributed across all of Europe, parts of cental Asia, Japan, Korea, Australia, New Zealand and most of North America. Did hominins that exploited this environment move along this corridor? In Africa, it is mostly absent, and also in southern and souteastern Asia, as well as South and Central America. Were Neanderhtals and Denisovans adapted to using this type of resource?



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Friday, October 16, 2026

Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)


This is the final post of the Lovelock Cave redheaded "giants" (Sixth in the Series). In my previous posts I have discussed the information gathered by the first Western person to visit the cave, John T. Reid.


This is the full series of posts on Lovelock Cave's "giants":

  • Post 1
  • Post 2
  • Post 3
  • Post 4
  • Post 5
  • Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)
  • January 2014 post mentioning Lovelock Cave.


Reid obtained this information from the local Paiute natives, who told him about their oral history and myths. These accounts tell us about a group of tall, redheaded people who were tule-eaters (tule is a variety of bulrush). They were the original people in this area, having arrived before the Paiute. They were well adapted to a lacustrine and fluvial environment, that had gradually been vanishing since the end of the Last Ice Age.


Reid called them Si-te-cah (redheaded tule-eaters). They vanished without a trace because the Paiute exterminated them during a war that lasted several years, and ended at Lovelock Cave. Some versions sayt that a few of these readheaded people managed to get away, making it to Lake Tule and Pit River in Northeastern California.


Summary of the Facts


  • Reid's main informants were Sarah Winnemucca and her nephew Gilbert Natchez (he was the grandson of the Paiute Chief Winnemucca, who was Sarah's father; and the son of Sarah's brother, Natchez Winnemucca). Other natives, and locals also mentioned the readheaded people:
    Sarah: they were "barbarians", people who ate the dead, cannibals, "people eaters". She added that they had "reddish hair" and that she owned a dress made with it.
    Mr. Mah-Wee said the dress existed, and had reddish-brown hair, obtained from the Si-te-cah (tule-eaters).
    Gilbert: They came from the Southwest, were "redheaded" and "very tall" they had spears but not arrows, and dogs with peaky, upright ears. They were also identfied with the "Umatilla's" or Pitt River or Modoc Indians (whe were lacustrine people).
    Taylor says they were the original inhabitants of this area when the Paiute arrived (c. 1000 AD according to Sutton). The Paiute would replace them.
    Bow-E-An (aka "Skinny Dave"): He was the grandson of Natchez and great-nephew of Winnemucca , narrated how his father, Pas-sa Dave (aka "Captain Dave") said they had reddish brown hair and some of them "were very tall". He also called them "Si-te-cah which means 'Tule Eaters'."
  • Lowe and Harrington who excavated Lovelock cave in 1912 and 1924, respectively, added more information: the Paiute called the "ancient people the name sai-duka’a, “tule-eaters,” a name which might be applied to any people with this habit. This may account for the application of the name or its shortened form sai’i to the Pit River Indians and the form Saidyuka [sic] to Indians of eastern Oregon".
  • Comment. In the different soucrces there are several references associating these redheaded giants with the Pit River and Lake Tule (Modoc) people. They lived in NE California and across the border, in southeastern Oregon. They were well adapted to their lakes and rivers habitat. Perhaps this similarity with the lifestyle of the Si-te-cah people led to this connection between both ethnic groups, redheads and Modocs. I will mention this in detail further down.
  • Reid believed they were Neanderthals. A newspaper article about Reid said he called them "red-heads, known scientifically as the Sid-ucah [sic] or Neanderthal race."
    While the local Paiute had "round" skulls, that is, brachycephalic, the redheaded tule-eaters had elongated crania, that is, dolichocephalic. In this, they resemble the Paleoindians (Lagoa Santa, Kennewick Man), and also Neanderthals and Denisovans were long-skulled humans.
  • Natchez added that there was a child-eating "large beast" that lived in the area in the past, called "Ooh-queetz". Reid mentioned a similar creature, a "cave man" called "Pi-Ee-tsah."
  • There were other "Tule eating" natives in California besides the Modocs at Lake Tule, and Pit River; these were the Yokut speakers from Lake Tulare near Fresno and Tulare, CA. The latter believed in a "Hairy Man", a wild-man, similar to bigfoot. They called it "Mayak datat" or "Sunsunut". One of the articles I quoted suggests it was a bigfoot.

Discussion


The now desertic and arid environment at Lovelock, Nevada is very different to the humid conditions that prevailed there when vast lakes covered the Great Basin Region in Nevada and Utah before the end of the last Ice Age. There were people who lived in that lacustrine habitat, thriving on the fish, game and plants that grew in the wetlands surrounding the lakes.


These were the first people in the area, and they were very different from the later arrivals like the Paiute or Shosone.


Baker et al., 2000 using the basket-making techiques of these people was unique, and "has no ethnographic correlates anywhere in North America. The appearance and disappearance of this textile from the Western Great Basin demonstrates a rare technological turnover within a regional basketry sequence characteristic of population replacement" (highlight is mine). The Numic speaking Paiute used "totally different [methods]" to make their baskets.


The replacement of the original population took place ~1000 AD. Baker et al., clearly state that this replacaement ".., means that there was a non-Numic population living in the area before the ancestors of the Northern Paiute arrived."


Who were these people? They were definitely Paleo-Indians, or probably an earlier population, with elongated heads. Their perfect adaptation to the lakes suggests that they had evolved over millennia in contact with this environment. An environment that has a long history in the Great Basin Region and Califnornia.


Lake Tulare in South Central California and its predecessor, Lake Corcoran span a period starting over 750,000 years ago. The Great Basin Lakes formed time and time again over the past 2 million years.


Reid's belief that these people were Neanderthal, due to their skull shape, is probably valid. But, I would suggest that they were Denisovans. These have dolichocephalic skulls like Neanderthals and the readheaded giants, but, unlike the Neanderthals, Denisovans were were big (See my post Denisovans were very tall people!).


I am not convinced about the bigfoot theory, it is likely that the natives had wild-men myths. In fact it is a shared heritage common to most human groups. Wild men, ogres, trolls, hairy giants are found across the world. It could be feasible that the later arrivals, Homo sapiens assigned a primitive child-eating, child-kidnapping behavior to other hominins (wild-men) that arrived earlier to America (Denisovans, Neanderthals, Homo erectus). This would explain the tule eaters description as barbarians and cannibals given by Sarah Winnemucca.


A very wild and farfetched idea is that the redhaired people were of a more primitive kind, for instance gigantopithecus, a giant-sized relative of the orangutans (who have red or orange fur, though we don't know what was the color of gigantopithecus fur). They may have been able to make tools, but it is an implausible possibility.


Red Hair is a unique trait


Readheaded people are not at all common, only 2 to 3% of the total human population have red hair (Source). Red hair or brown hair is extremely rare among Native Americans, who tend to have jet black hair.


The official explanation for the red hair of the Lovelock remains is that chemicals and microbes decolored the hair of the mummified bodies, or that ochre was applied to the hair, coloring it red. Both are valid explanations.


In my 2014 post about Lovelock and the nearby Spirit Cave remains (which also have red hair), I wrote that "Red hair is not at all common among Amerindians or East Asians but Neanderthal had the MC1R gene (melanocortin 1 receptor) associated with red hair in humans... So maybe a band of relict Neanderthals lived in Nevada until quite recently and were wiped out by the Paiute." I made this remark based on a paper by Lalueza-Fox, C., Römpler, H., Hofreiter M., et al., (2007). A melanocortin 1 receptor allele suggests varying pigmentation among Neanderthals. Science, October 25, 2007.


The authors found a mutation in two Neanderthal specimens, a variant that has not yet been detected in humans, the "R307G substitution" in the MC1R (melanocortin 1 receptor) protein that regulates skin and hair color. This substitution causes a partial "loss of function" in the protein, and in human MC1R, a similar loss of function causes pale white skin and red hair. The paper notes that the "Neanderthal individuals that may have had reduced pigmentation levels, possibly even similar to the pale skin color and/or red hair observed in modern humans" and speculates if it could have been the result of selection allowing a better absorption of sunlight in northern Eurasia for vitamin D production in the skin.


As this mutation is different to the one found in humans the paper rules out gene flow and suggest that human and Neanderthals developed red hair through a "convergent evolution of reduced-function MC1R alleles." They note that at least 1% of Nenderthals carried this mutation.


Since 2007, analysis of other Neanderthal specimens has failed to detect this R307G substitution. It must be very rare. These other Neanderthals carry another variant that they passed on to modern humans (see Ding et al., 2014). It is the "Val92Met variant, a loss-of-function variant in MC1R that is associated with multiple dermatological traits including skin color and photoaging. Frequency of this Neanderthal introgression is low in Europeans (∼5%), moderate in continental East Asians (∼30%), and high in Taiwanese aborigines (60–70%)." It causes freckles in Japanese people! Could it cause red hair in Neanderthals?


The modern human mutation causing reduced function on MC1R is ancient. Harding et al., 2000 noted that "for the European red hair–associated Arg151Cys and Arg160Trp variants, we estimate an age of ∼80,000 years." This is far older than modern human remains in Europe. Furthermore, the authors calculated that "the MC1R variants Val60Leu, Val92Met, and Arg163Gln may trace back to ancestors in Eurasian populations existing 250,000–100,000 years ago." Now this date predates the Out of Africa (OOA) event, meaning that these people would have lived in Africa (but there are no redheaded people there). This is inconsistent with the OOA migration. Harding et al., aware of this discrepancy: "... an incompatibility arises between estimated ages in the range of 250,000–100,000 years, for non-African MC1R allelic variation, and ages, from fossil evidence, of ⪱100,000 years for the dispersal of modern humans outside Africa and the Middle East." (They try to explain it away to adapt the dates to the OOA theory).


The point is that red hair is an ancient trait shared by Humans and Neanderthals. Do we know if Denisovans carry this trait? No, we don't. It seems that they don't have the MC1R variants.


But, Tenesa et al., 2018 pointed out that "MC1R only explains 73% of the SNP heritability for red hair in UK Biobank, and in fact most individuals with two MC1R variants have blonde or light brown hair. We identify other genes contributing to red hair, the combined effect of which accounts for ~90% of the SNP heritability" So there are other genes that can cause red hair.


And even in the MC1R there are more variants that can produce redheaded people. A recent paper by Kashyap et al., 2026 searched for mutations in the MC1R gene in 11,000 Indians and found 9 new variants and 12 "ultra-rare" ones, that make skin pigmentation lighter, and an extremely rare, unique variant in a girl from Southern India, that caused red hair.


Then we have an area with a high level of Denisovan introgression, Melanesia where people have a different allele that causes fair hair and also red hair. It is a switch from arginine to cysteine known as the R93C mutation in the TYRP1 (tyrosinase-related protein 1) gene on chromosome 9. Did this mutation reach Polynesia in an ancient wave? I have posted about a pre-Maoir people who are said to have been the original inhabitants of New Zealand, the Urukehu, fair, and redheaded. Then we have the "Ehu" (note the term "ehu" in Urukehu, and Ehu. It means a reddish or brown tint in the hair) of Hawaii was reported by H. D. Alexander, 1893 (p.24): "The existence among them of a strain of lighter colored people with sandy or reddish hair called in Hawaii ehu and in New Zealand kehu may be due to intermingling with another race either in India or the Malay Archipelago."


The Denisovans could have reached America some 400,000 years ago, and adapted to the empty New World. These tule eaters could have been thei last remnants.


Giants


Reid believed they were giants, and the figures he calculated were gigantic. As I have shown, later, formal studies give them a tall yet normal height. This discrepancy requires an explanation.


In my first post, James Hart, who dug the caves, removing guano in 1911 unearthed very large skeletons: a man measuring 6 feet 6 inches (1.98 m), he described as gigantic. Where did this skeleton end up? It does not seem likely that it became part of Reid's collection, the one measured by modern scholars, which yielded "shorter" or more "normal" heights. The source I cited states that "It is assumed Reid must have collected these specimens from the Pyramid Lake area and in the Humboldt Sink. The time period to which these remains date is undetermined, as there were no directly associated artifacts or archaeological context. Consequently the skeletal material from the Reid Collection was grouped together and treated during this analysis as if all the individuals were from one time period." So, perhaps none of the cave people were measured, and Reid collected bones from Paiute burials in the region.


We will never know for certain because, as stated in the Humboldt Museum (Winnemucca, NV) website, "In respect for American Indians and compliance with NAGPRA, the display was removed. All human remains have been repatriated. HUMBOLDT MUSEUM DOES NOT POSSESS ANY HUMAN REMAINS OR FUNERARY ITEMS." The remains are lost to science in the name of a supposed (actually non-existent) link between Paiute people and these other humans who were not even Paiute!


The Modoc & Pit River connection


There were several references to the Modoc natives from Lake Tule and Pit River in the stories of the Paiute people about the redheaded giants. Why?


In my first post of this series I quoted Lowe and Harrington as saying "In the Mind of the Northern Paiute they [the tule-eaters] are often associated with the Pit River Indians among whom a remnant [of the redheaded giants] are even supposed to exist today. The Pit River Indians are called by the Paiute sai’i, which is also the name of the ancient people, but the possible reason for this is that both peoples are held in contempt." In other words, the Paiute gave the Modoc (Pit River Indians) the same name they had given the redhead giants: "sai'i" or "ancient". Which is revealing, because it assigns antiquity to these people, coinciding with the idea accepted by modern anthropologists, that they were the first inhabitants of this area of the Great Basin.


Lowe and Harrington also wrote that "The Northern Paiute applied to the ancient people the name sai-duka’a, “tule-eaters,” a name which might be applied to any people with this habit. This may account for the application of the name or its shortened form sai’i to the Pit River Indians and the form Saidyuka to Indians of eastern Oregon."


These Saidyuka were a small band, comprised of five tribes that lived close to Pyramid Lake in NW Nevada. that were displaced by the Paiute into Oregon (Source). They were of Shoshone origin, and therefore related to the Paiute, unlike the "ancient" lake dwellers.


In my second post I mentioned that bothh authors noted that "In some versions a few escaped and were chased to the northwest of Lovelock Cave; in other versions, they ended up as far away as Tule Lake, California."


In my third post, I quote Reid, who gives Gilbert Natchez's account: "the Piutes followed, and when they found that the intruders who Natchez called "Umatilla's" [sic] but other Piutes refer to as the Pitt River or Modoc Indians, had taken refuge in the cave... but other stories go on to state that the intruders were driven to the northwestward". Note that the Umatilla's did not have a river or lake habitat, instead they lived on the Columbia River plateau in Oregon, they used horses.


Reid also mentions that the "Si-te-cah (redheaded tule-eaters) ... who escaped this confrontation were driven north towards the Pitt River."


It seems that the "Pitt" (actually Pit) River natives, the Modoc people, who also lived by Lake Tule in NE California were considered tule-eaters. The versions stating that the survivors of Lovelock Cave massacre moved northwest, and the reference to the Umatilla people of southern Oregon all point at an association in the minds of the Paiutes, between the Nevada tule-eaters and those other ethnic groups, contemporary tribes, living in NE California and Oregon.


This association may have been promoted by the similar lifestyles of Modocs and Lovelock redheads, adapted to lake and river environments. But it is very likely that the Lovelock people did not belong to the Modoc, or Tulare, ethnic groups. They were the ancient inhabitants who settled there during the wet periods preceding the Last Glacial Maximum in the Great Basin Region.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Lovelock "giants" revisited (Post 5)


Continuing with the Lovelock Cave redheaded giants series, in this post we will explore the comment made by Dorothy P. Dansie in her 1975 article, published in the Nevada Historical Society Quarterly, Fall 1975 (John T. Reid's Case for the Redheaded Giants) in which she added a curious piece of information: a cryptid, man-eating, hairy giant in the lore of the Paiute people.


After recording the native stories about the redheaded people that were exterminated in Lovelock Cave, Dansie noted that Gilbert Natchez, the Paiute friend of John T. Reid, who had told him about Lovelock Cave, had also told him about a native myth about a child-eating creature.


This is the full series of posts on Lovelock Cave's "giants":

  • Post 1
  • Post 2
  • Post 3
  • Post 4
  • Post 5
  • Lovelock Cave redheaded giants - Conclusion (post 6)
  • January 2014 post mentioning Lovelock Cave.


The monster that ate children


This is what Dansie wrote about Natchez and the native tales:


"Off the subject, but perhaps related, is another tale told that day by Natchez of some large beasts which had once roamed the Humboldt region. They were dangerous carnivorous animals which devoured unprotected children and he claimed that Indian mothers still threatened their children with, "Ooh-queetz will get you, if you are not good." Reid adds that he had heard similar mention of a "cave man" who would get the children if they were unruly. Another term for a terrifying child-eating beast was Pi-Ee-tsah."


I have encountered similar myths in Patagonia, child, and woman-eating creatures, hairy man-like beasts living in caves. They probably reflect the megafaunal creatures that existed until some 10,000 years ago (sloths, large cave bears, sabre tooth felines, etc.) In this case it seems that Dansie added the story because somehow, she believed they were linked to the redheaded "giants" that lived in the region. Perhaps a tribal memory about them.


The tule-eaters


Before looking into the hairy giants myths, I'd like to refer to the the "real" people who lived in this area by the lakes, who were well adapted to its environment. They were, according to the Paiute, tule-eaters. The ones that have been documented histocrically, and have survived until today, lived in California: the Modocs in the Northeastern corner of the state, and the Yokuts in central California, along the San Joaquin River Valley.


As mentioned in a previous post (see: Modocs on Pitt River (and Lake Tule), and Lake Tulare in the south) these people based their subsistence on the tule bulrush (Schoenoplectus acutus). They made houses, mats, boats, baskets, nets, and footwear out of the rushes. They ate the tender shoots, and ground the roots into tule flour. Indeed they were tule-eaters. They also hunted the wildlife that lived in the wetlands around Lake Tulare and Lake Tule.


It may seem an adaptation to a strange, possibly unique environment, but it wasn't. The region was completely different 15,000 years ago. Nevada, western Utah, southeastern California and northern Arizona may be arid nowadays, but back then the region was very humid, and had many vast lakes.


It would have been an ideal environment for the first Paleoindians, providing water, food, and natural resources. The Paiute people were latecomers to the region. Mark Q. Sutton suggested in 1958, that the Northern Paiute reached the region around 1000 AD. "presumably supplanting earlier inhabitants" Yes, they did, they exterminated the tule-eaters.


During the Pleistocene Ice Age periods over the past two million years (a period of time long enough to cover potential migrations of archaic hominins into America), glacial ice melt and grater rainfall formed a network of large lakes across the Great Basin Region.


It gets its name because it is a closed drainage basin (no outflow into the oceans that surround North America).


At the end of the Pleistocene, deglaciation brought with it a gobal warming period and climate change that altered rainfall patterns and led to an increased dryness in that region. As arid conditions set in, evaporation increased and the lakes started to shribnk. Water levels dropped, and the lakes broke up into smaller ones. Most of them dried up quickly while others shrunk to their current size some 8,000 years ago. Their ancient coastlines are etched high up, along the valleys that were once filled with freshwater.


Now, this area has former lake beds that became salt flats or sinks that seasonally carry water. However, some of the modern lakes, are remnants of those vast Ice Age lakes: Great Salt Lake in Utah, Lake Utah, Bear Lake, Lake Mono, Carson Lake, Lake Tahoe, etc.) The following map, prepared by the U.S. Geological Survey (Paleoclimate Variability of the American Southwest) shows, the ancient (dark blue) and modern (pale blue) lakes of the Great Basin Region.


Paleolakes Nevada Utah and California Great Basin Region
Pleistocene Lakes in the Great Basin Region. California, Nevada, Utah. U.S.G.S.

The area around Lovelock contained a vast lake, Lake Lahontan, with a surface area of 22,000 km2 (8,500 sq. mi.) it was almost 270 m deep (900 ft.) An ideal setting for humans to thrive.


Not far from this lake, in the region west of the Sierra Nevada, south of Sacramento, California (and possibly north, along what now is the Sacramento Valley), was another vast lake (Lake Corcoran) that was formed around 760,000 years ago and emptied around 650,000 years ago into the newly formed San Francisco Bay.


In the Southern Part of the Californian Central Valley some parts of Lake Corcoran survived. Nowadays, the San Joaquin River runs along it, with a SE-NW course. It has its sources in the Sierra Nevada, to the East, and its valley is enclosed on the west by the Southern Coastal Ranges, that run parallel to the Pacific coast. Just south of Fresno, was a large lake (Lake Tulare).


Below is the map prepared by Narváez, of Alta California, who visited California in 1822, and published it in 1830. You can see the "Ciénagas de Tulares" (Tulares Marshes - after the Tule bulrushes) running along the San Joaquin River Valley, south of Sacramento all the way to Bakersfield. I highlighted some landmarks on the map.


Narvaez map 1830 Alta California

Narvaez probably exagerated in the extent of the wetlands, basing his knowledge on native informants. But we do know that Lake Tulare was the largest freshwater lake west of the Mississippi River. It covered an area of over 1,750 km2 (~700 sq. mi.) which could grow to almost 1,100 sq. mi. (2,800 km2) during very wet spells.


The surrounding areas were marshes. Starting in the 1870s, the lake was dissecated to make room for farming, the rivers dammed and the overflow used for irrigation.


Something similar took place in NW California where Lake Tule - also named for the bulrushes, (53 km2 or 13,000) was drained in the 1920s. It was much bigger in the past, covering between 50,000 and 100,000 acres (200 to 400 km2) depending on the snowpack and precipitation.


The native people who lived by these lakes were displaced by Western settlers after 1850, and their unique lake-based lifestyles vanished. Below is a short summary about these people.


The Modoc


These were mentioned by John Reid's informants, as the source (in some versions) or the survivors (in other versions) of the giant readheaded tule-eating people who were exterminated by the Paiute in Lovelock.


The Modocs lived on both sides of the Oregon-California border, around Lake Tule and along the Lost River that feeds it. Contact with westerners in the late 1700s introduced disease (smallpox) that wiped out most of them. Then came the pioneers heading for Oregon in the 1850s which led to war, uprooting and relocation with other ethnic groups (Klamaths, and Paiutes). Finally they rebelled and war broke out in 1872. They were defeated and some relocated to the Indian Territories (now Oklahoma), where a band of Modoc still live, in Miami, OK. (Source).


The Lake Tulare People


The first people of Tulare spoke the Yokut language, and were not related to the Modoc, they spoke a different language. But they shared the same lacustrine environment and adaptations. Over 35,000 people spread into more than 40 tribes lived in the region. The Tachi Yokuts of Leemore, CA, and the Tule River Indian Tribe of Porterville, CA are the current remnants of the tribe. (Source).


The Mayak-Datat - "Hairy Man"


Just like the Paiute, who had their myths about the child-eating caveman, the Lake Tulare natives also have oral traditions about a "hairy man". Their ancestors depicted the creature in their rock art.


An article by Kathy Moskowitz Strain, 2012 (The Relict Hominoid Inquiry 1:1-12, Mayak Datat: The Hairy Man Pictographs) decribes the myth and the rock art. The following image is a composite adapted from Strain's article:


hairy man pictographsy, Yokut native Americans
Three different "hairy men" (Father, Mother, and Child). K.M. Stain, 2012

The paintings are between 700 and 2000 years old, most likely 500-1000 years old, and represent animals, and the "Hairy Man". Strain says that the "Tule River Indians equate Hairy Man to Bigfoot".


The natives call it Mayak datat or sunsunut. It is depicted as a hairy biped. There is a male, a female and a "child" painting at the site. The creatures have five finters, and "an unusually rounded head, suggestive of a sagittal crest."


The story of the Hairy Man can be found on the Tulare people's website , and I quote it below:


"Big Foot, The Hairy Man


Big Foot was a creature that was like a great big giant with long, shaggy hair. His long shaggy hair made him look like a big animal. He was good in a way, because he ate the animals that might harm people. He kept the Grizzly Bear, Mountain Lion, Wolf, and other larger animals away. During hot summer nights all the animals would come out together down from the hills to drink out of the Tule River. Big Foot liked to catch animals down by the river. He would eat them up bones and all.
It was pleasant and cool down by the river on hot summer nights. That is when grown ups liked to take a swim. Even though people feared that Big Foot, the hairy man, might come to the river, people still liked to take a swim at night.
Parents always warned their children, "Don't go near the river at night. You may run into Big Foot." Now Big Foot usually eats animals, but parents said, "If he can't find any animals and he is very hungry, he will eat you. Big Foot, the hairy man, doesn't leave a speck or trace. He eats you up bones and all. We won't know where you have gone or what has happened to you."
Some people say Big Foot, the hairy man, still roams around the hills near Tule River. He comes along the trail at night and scares a lot of people. When you hear him you know it is something very big because he makes a big sound, not a little sound. Children are cautioned not to make fun of his picture on the painted rock or play around that place because he would hear you and come after you.
Parents warned their children, "You are going to meet him on the road if you stay out too late at night." The children have learned always to come home early.
Told by Ruby Bays Jennie Franco From Big foot and other stories.
"


Similar stories can be found among other native groups living in the area (see "Rock Giants" in C. Hart Merriam's book The Dawn of the World Myths and Weird Tales Told by the Mewan [Miwok] Indians of California, published in 1910. The Mewan are a different group from the Yokut, but share the myths of man-eating giants.


Comments


I am skeptical about bigfoot or a similar cryptid. Some have suggested it could be a species similar to the Asian gigantopithecus, but it seems unlikely. However, this "hairy man" and the other references to child-eating cavemen, and rock men, may indicate the presence of "wild men". Wild men are a common myth in South America and Patagonia, and in my posts I have suggested that they were exactly that, wild hominins, probably Neanderthals, Denisovans or Homo erectus. In my next post, the final one in this series, I will go into this hypothesis in detail.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 
Hits since Sept. 2009:
Copyright © 2009-2025 by Austin Victor Whittall.
Todos los derechos reservados por Austin Whittall para esta edición en idioma español y / o inglés. No se permite la reproducción parcial o total, el almacenamiento, el alquiler, la transmisión o la transformación de este libro, en cualquier forma o por cualquier medio, sea electrónico o mecánico, mediante fotocopias, digitalización u otros métodos, sin el permiso previo y escrito del autor, excepto por un periodista, quien puede tomar cortos pasajes para ser usados en un comentario sobre esta obra para ser publicado en una revista o periódico. Su infracción está penada por las leyes 11.723 y 25.446.

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means - electronic, mechanical, photocopy, recording, or any other - except for brief quotations in printed reviews, without prior written permission from the author, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review.

Please read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy before accessing this blog.

Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy

Patagonian Monsters - https://patagoniamonsters.blogspot.com/