Translate

Guide to Patagonia's Monsters & Mysterious beings

I have written a book on this intriguing subject which has just been published.
In this blog I will post excerpts and other interesting texts on this fascinating subject.

Austin Whittall


Showing posts with label pre-Columbian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pre-Columbian. Show all posts

Monday, February 9, 2026

The Welsh discovery of America, the Madoc myth


Online you can find many pages dedicated to a Welsh prince named Madoc, who set sail from Wales roughly one century before his country was conquered by the English, and settled in North America.


I came across an interesting book, that predates these webpages by 150 years: America Discovered by the Welsh in 1170 A.D., by Benjamin H. Bowen (1876).


madoc web pages
Google results: Madoc.

It is fun to read, and mentions among other things, the white, bearded indians of Baroa (on page 140) (I have posted about them), von Humboldt's reference to white Indians in the Orinoco region. It describes linguistic links, and stories told by those who settled and explored North America.


There is a also a long epic poem "Madoc" published in 1805 by Robert Southey (1774-1843) that details the mythic voyage from Wales to America, but not to what is now the U.S., but to Mexico, where he met the Aztecs (Aztlan). But is it based on facts?


Lhoyd's History of Wales, 1584


There is a much older written reference about Madoc by David Powel, published in 1584, and it is found in his work The historie of Cambria, now called Wales: a part of the most famous yland of Brytaine, written in the Brytish language aboue two hundreth yeares past: tr. into English by H. Lhoyd... Corrected, augmented, and continued out of records and best approoued authors, by Dauid Powel (see pages 166-167), quoted below.


The book, in its introduction, says that the official Welsh records it mentions were compiled by Caradoc of Lancaruan and later continued until 1270, and conserved in two Welsh abbeys. It was later translated into English by Humffrey Lhoyd (1527-1568). David Powel added onto Lhoyd's work.


The story of Madoc is the following: When the Welsh King Owen Gwyneth died in 1170, his sons and heirs began fighting among themselves for the throne. One of them, Macoc opted out and set sail across the Atlantic to find a new place to settle and reign over. Below is the story of his adventures:


"...Madoc another of Owen Gwyneth his sonnes left the land in contention betwixt his brethren, and prepared certaine ships with men and munition, and sought aduentures by seas, sailing West, and leauing the coast of Ireland so far north, that he came to a land unknowen, where he saw manie strange things. This land must needs be some part of that countrie of which the Spaniardes affirme themselues to be the first finders sith Hannos time; for by reason and order of Cosmographie, this land, to the which Madoc came, must needs be some part of Noua Hispania or Florida. Whereupon it is manifest, that that countrie was long before by Brytaines discovered, afore either Columbus or Americus Vesputius lead anie Spaniards thither. Of the viage and returne of this Madoc there be manie fables fained, as the common people doo vse in distance of place and length of time rather to augment than to diminish: but sure it is, that there he was. And after he had returned home and declared the pleasant and fruitfull countries that he had seene without inhabitants; and vpon the contrarie part, for what barren and wild ground his brethren and nephues did murther one another: he prepared a number of ships, and got with him such men and women as were desirous to liue in quietnes, and taking leaue of his freends tooke his iournie thitherward againe. Therefore it is to be presupposed, that he and his people inhabited part of those countries; for it appeareth by Francis Loues, that in Acusanus and other places, the people honored the crosse: whereby it may be gathered that Christians had beene there, before the comming of the Spaniards. But bicause this people were not manie, they folowed the maners of the land, they came vnto, and vsed the language they found there.

†‡† This Madoc arriuing in that Westerne countrie, vnto the which he came, in the yeare 1170. left most of his people there: and returning backe for more of his owne nation, acquaintance and freends, to inhabite that faire and large countrie: went thither againe with ten sailes, as I find noted by Gutyn Owen. Gutyn Owen. I am of opinion that the land, wherevnto he came, was some part of Mexico: the causes which make me to thinke so be these.

1 The common report of the inhabitants of that countrie, which affirme, that their rulers descended from a strange nation, that came thither from a farre countrie: which thing is confessed by Mutezuma king of that countrie, in his oration made for quieting of his people, at his submission to the king of Castile, Hernando Curteis being then present, which is laid downe in the Spanish Chron cles of the conquest of the West Indies.

2 The Brytish words and names of places, vsed in that countrie euen to this daie, doo argue the same as when they talke togither, they use this word Gwrando, which is, Hearken or listen. Also they haue a certeine bird with a white head, which they call Pengwin, that is, white head. But the Iland of Corroeso, the cape of Bryton, the riuer of Gwyndor, and the white rocke of Pengwyn, which be all Brytish or Welsh words, doo manifestlie shew that it was that countrie which Madoc and his people inhabited.
"


The footnotes 1 and 2 were taken from Sir George Peckham's true Report of the late discoueries, published in The Principal Navigations, Voyages, Traffiques and Discoveries of the English Nation. Vol. XIII. America. Part II. by Richard Hakluyt. See p. 14. (and here, Chapter III)


Context


It has been suggested that this reference to Madoc and America during the Elizabethan period was created to set a precedent and first discovery by the British Welsh people and justify England's colonial pretences in America during Queen Elizabeth the First's time. In 1586 the English established the short-lived English colony of Roanoke Island, in what is now North Carolina, and it failed. However, in 1584, Sir Walter Raleigh named the eastern coast Virgina, in honor of the Queen. Sir Humphrey Gibson claimed Newfoundland for England in 1583. Was Madoc "invented" to justify the English Crown's claim? (see p. 281 in the work quoted above, which uses Madoc to justify these territorial claims.)


Peckham quotes David Ingram, a British sailor who said he walked 2,000 km (3,200 miles) from Tampico in the Gulf of Mexico to Maine - Nova Scotia in 1566-69. He lived among the natives. It was Ingram who mentions the word "Gwrando" a Welsh greeting used by the natives. He also mentions them using the same name to identify penguins. But note that these are not those found in the southern Oceans, but the great auk (Pinguinus impennis), which was known as penguin or garefowl. It was exterminated by the mid-1800s. It is not related to the Southern penguins which were named after them, as they looked very similar (black and white, swimming, flightless birds). The English word "penguin" comes from the Welsh "pen" "gwyn" "white" and "head", respectively. Referring to the auk. Ingram was rescued by a French ship in 1569, in Nova Scotia. His journey was recorded, but that will be the subject of another post.


Other later mentions of Madoc


Madoc sailing
Madoc Leaving Wales. Source

The image above comes from A Popular History of the United States (p. 66 onwards) by William Bryant and Sydney Gay (1888), which tells about Madoc and of reports from the late 1600s of a pale-skinned Native American tribe speaking a British language in North America. With later reports from the 1770s and 1780s, a tribe called Mandans, who had Welsh traits:


"Among them were in use certain words in which is a resemblance or a fancied resemblance to the old British language. In the manufacture of their pottery and in the making of blue beads they are said to have shown a superiority over the ordinary savage. Mr Catlin believed them to be a cross theory and between the Indians and the Welsh and is inclined to accept a theory favored also by some other writers that the Mandans are the descendants of the Mound Builders and that the builders of those numerous earth works were the people originating in Madoc's Colony. The boat they used Catlin says was more like the coracle of the Welsh than the canoe of other Indians and he asserts that in complexion in the color of their hair and eyes they seemed rather to be allied to the white than the red race"


Closing Comments


Madoc's voyages is an interesting story. But, is it True? It would be hard to find Welsh genes among the surviving Native Americans of the East Coast. They were decimated and expelled from their territories as the European settlers occupied the eastern seabord. Then the Indian Removal Act promoted by President Andrew Jackson and signed by him on May 28, 1830 led to the forced removal of all surviving Native American tribes in the East, to what is now Oklahoma, beyond the Mississippi River.


Did the Welsh bring Old World diseases with them? Did they share their European technology like iron smelting, farming, dogs, horses, or cattle with the natives? If they did, it seems that just as with the Vikings before them, who set up a small settlement at L'Anse aux Meadows, in Newfoundland c.1000 AD, the Natives didn't adopt the new knowledge, and probably liquidated the settlers, or expelled them.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Sunday, January 18, 2026

Prehispanic Leprosy back in the 1890s


In yesterday's post I mentioned some studies that investigated the "American" strain of leprosy, which dates back to pre-Columbian times. It is caused by a bacteria called Mycobacterium lepromatosis. Today's post shows that over 135 years ago, some scientists suspected that there had been cases of pre-Columbian leprosy in America.


Muñiz and Ashmead


According to Máximo Farro and Irina Podgorni (2015) ("Pre-Columbian Moulages" Huacos, mummies and photograps in the International controversy over precolumbian diseases 1894-1910a Medicine nei secoli arte e scienza, 27/2 (2015) 631-654), it was Manuel Antonio Muñiz (1861-1897), a physician who had studied medicine in the San Marcos University in Lima, who in 1886 published the first article on pre-Hispanic leprosy. He mentioned that the Spanish conquistador, Gonzalo Jiménez de Quesada (1509-1579), who had founded Bogotáa (now the capital of Colombia) in 1538, had become infected with leprosy in America.


Muñiz also collected native artifacts and skeletal remains, some of which he interpreted showed signs of the deformation caused by leprosy. He shared his collection with during different international medical and anthropological meetings, and in 1895 published a formal paper on his findings about leprosy in America.


Muñiz startled the scientific world, if there was leprosy in America before the arrival of Europeans, it meant that either it was taken there by previous, unknown voyagers to the New World, or, it had an independent origin there.


At that same time, an American physician who had specialized in leprology, Albert Sydney Ashmead (1850-1911), also published on this subject. Ashmead was one of the founders of the International Leprosy Congress, and defended these ancient American cases of leprosy againts the critics who suggested that the lesions were not leprous, but syphilitic or caused by leishmaniasis .


text

Latcham's paper.

The image above shows the title of the paper by Robert Lehmann-Nitsche (1899) "Lepra Precolombina ensayo crítico" (Pre-Columbian Leprosy, critical essay) Revsta Museo de La Plata Vol. 9, p.337. In it, he reviews the history and evidence supporting or disproving an endemic leprosy in america. The author concludes that there was a disease that caused the lesions reported by Ashmead and Muñiz, but that he didn't believe it was leprosy.


The outcome of endless scholarly discussions was that there had been no leprosy in America before the Europeans brought the Old World strain of leprosy to the continent after 1492.


As we now know, Muñiz and Ashmead were right. There was an American strain that caused leprosy, an ancient one, distinct from the Old World variety.


Further Reading


Pre-Columbian leprosy, Albert S. Ashmead. American Medical Association, 1895.


Pre-Columbian Leprosy. Albert S. Ashmead, M.D., JAMA, February 10, 1900 1900;XXXIV;(6):379. doi:10.1001/jama.1900.02460060063020


Regarding Pre Columbian Leprosy, Dr. H. Polakowsky, Berlin p.260 May 1900. The St. Louis Medican and Surgical Journal. 78.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Sunday, January 4, 2026

Fusang. The Chinese discovery of America c.450-490 AD


Fusang is an account written by a Chinese Buddhist monk named Hoei-schin which tells about a Chinese voyage which took place in the late fifth century AD, to a country called Fusang, located far to the east, 20,000 li (Chinese miles) from China, which some believe was America, and specifically, Mexico. The Fusang account also mentions a previous visit that took place earlier, in 458 AD, involving some Buddhist monks who took their religion with them to Fusang.


You can find the account digitalized online (Fusang : or, The discovery of America by Chinese Buddhist priests in the fifth century. Leland, Charles Godfrey and Neumann, Karl Friedrich, 1875.


The name Fusang is that of a Chinese plant, said to resemble one they found in the country they visited, which the notes and comments by Friedrich, translated from German to English by Leland, identify with the maguey.


The book is well balanced because it includes points of view that support the notion that Fusang was America, and others that say it is fiction. See this criticism as an example:


"'Hui-shen appears to have been a consummate humbug.' (Cf. 'The People of Central Asia,' by F. Hyacinth.) "I cannot, indeed, understand what ground we have for believing that Fusang is America..."


Earlier references about Fusang


There are older references on Fusang, as can be seen online here (1763), mentioning de Guignes, who is also mentioned here in 1761 (with a map showing Fusang), and earlier, in 1753.


There is also some disputed and controversial maps attributed to Marco Polo's travels to Asia that mention Fusang (See source) where it shows East Asia and Western North America, with "Focan = Fú Sāng (扶桑) [a mythical land to distant east of China and/or a mythical mulberry tree () growing there]"


Fusang in the 18th-century cartography


A map published in 1776 by Zatta, A., Nuove scoperte de’Russi al Nord del Mare del Sud si nell’Asia, che nell America. Venice. Shows the Northern Pacific, on the coast at Cape Fortuna, you can see "Fou-Sang", this is NW USA, roughly 50° Lat. North and it reads "Colonia de Chinesi" (Chinese Colony). Next to it is the mythical strait of Anian, which was believed to be a link to the Northwest Passage (to the Atlantic Ocean), and also marked the boundary between Asia and America, like Bering Strait does nowadays. The location is roughly where Cape Flattery and Juan de Fuca Strait are located. It can also bee seen in another map from 1768 (online here) which reads "Four Sang according to yc. Chinese geogr." with Puerto Bravo and Cabo Fortunes along its coast, and the Juan de Fuca Strait on its southern side. It is probably Vancouver Island (map).


Juan de Fuca's voyage was published in Hakluytus Posthumus, vol. XIV, p. 415, in 1825, as told by Michael Lok, who in 1596 met de Fuca in Venice.


north pacific map 1776
detail map of california, oregon, washington 1776
Zatta's map 1776, and detail showing Fou-Sang. Online, can be enlarged

Now, let's look at the text by Charles G. Leland, Karl F. Neumann, published in 1875.


The 1875 Text on Fusang


This is the literal translation of the original text:


"During the reign of the dynasty Tsi, in the first year of the year-naming, ' Everlasting Origin ' (a.d. 499), came a Buddhist priest from this kingdom, who bore the cloister-name of Hoei-schin, i.e., Universal Compassion, to the -present district of Hukuang, and those surrounding it, who narrated that Fusang is about twenty thousand Chinese miles in an easterly direction from Tahan, and east of the Middle Kingdom. Many Fusang trees grow there, whose leaves resemble the Dryanda cordifolia, the sprouts, on the contrary, resemble those of the bamboo-tree, and are eaten by the inhabitants of the land. The fruit is like a pear in form, but is red. From the bark they prepare a sort of linen which they use for clothing, and also a sort of ornamented stuff.
They have written characters in this land, and prepare paper from the bark of the Fusang. The people have no weapons, and make no wars ; but in the arrangements for the kingdom they have a northern and a southern prison. Trifling offenders were lodged in the southern prison, but those confined for greater offences in the northern ; so that those who were about to receive grace could be placed in the southern prison, and those who were not, in the northern. Those men and women who were imprisoned for life were allowed to marry. The boys resulting from these marriages were, at the age of eight years, sold as slaves ; the girls not until their ninth year. If a man of any note was found guilty of crimes, an assembly was held ; it must be in an excavated place." {Gruhe^ Grer. "a pit;" possibly within an embankment or circle of earth. — C. Gr. L.) " There they strewed ashes over him, and bade him farewell. If the offender was one of a lower class, he alone was punished ; but when of rank, the degradation was extended to his children and grandchildren. With those of the highest rank it attained to the seventh generation.
The name of the king is pronounced Ichi. The nobles of the first-class are termed Tuilu ; .of the second. Little Tuilu ; and of the third, Na-to-scha. "When the prince goes forth, he is accompanied by horns and trumpets. The colour of his clothes changes with the different years. In the two first of the ten-year cyclus they are blue ; in the two next, red ; in the two following, yellow ; in the two next, red ; and in the last two, black.
"


Oxen and Horses in Fusang (America?)


The text continues and mentions the locals have oxen, horses, and use the milk of deers. The notes mention that Humboldt had said there were two types of bovids in Mexico, and that some critics of the text had pointed out that there were no horses in America. The commentary argues the opposite: " "


" The horns of the oxen are so large that they hold ten bushels. They use them to contain all manner of things. Horses, oxen, and stags are harnessed to their waggons. Stags are used here as cattle are used in the Middle Kingdom, and from the milk of the hind they make butter. The red pears of the Fusang-tree keep good throughout the year. Moreover, they have apples and reeds. From the latter they prepare mats. No iron is found in this land ; but copper, gold, and silver are not prized, and do not serve as a medium of exchange in the market. "


The final part of the text is about marriage, and then it mentions a previous voyage of missionary Buddhist monks in 458 AD.


"Marriage is determined upon in the following manner : — The suitor builds himself a hut before the door of the house where the one longed for dwells, and waters and cleans the ground every morning and evening. When a year has passed by, if the maiden is not inclined to marry him, he departs ; should she be willing, it is completed; When the parents die, they fast seven days. For the death of the paternal or maternal grandfather they lament five days ; at the death of elder or younger sisters or brothers, uncles or aunts, three days. They then sit from morning to evening before an image of the ghost, absorbed in prayer, but wear no mourningclothes. When the king dies, the son who succeeds him does not busy himself for three years with State affairs.
In earlier times these people lived not according to the laws of Buddha. But it happened that in the second year-naming Great Light,' of Song (a.d. 458), five beggar-monks from the kingdom of Kipin went to this land, extended over it the religion of Buddha, and with it his holy writings and images. They instructed the people in the principles of monastic life, and so changed their manners.
"


The final part of the text mentions a tribe of Amazons! which is not translated in this work: "This land," he writes, "lies ahout a thousand Chinese miles in an easterly direction from Fusang, and is inhabited hy white people with very hairy bodies." The entire story is, however, intermixed with so. much fabulous matter, that it is not worth translating."


So if this has "fabulous" matter, why don't we consider other parts of the text as made up? It could all be false.


The domestic animals


On page 40, the book analyzes the deer, bovids, and horses:


"DOMESTIC ANIMALS.
The Aztecs had no beasts of draught or of burden. Horses were not found in the New World. The report of the Chinese missionary has, therefore, no connection with the later Mexican reigns. Two varieties of wild oxen with large horns ranged in herds on the plains of the Rio del Norte.3 These might have been tamed by the earlier inhabitants, and used as domestic animals. Stag's horns have been found in the ruins of Mexican buildings ; and Montezuma showed the Spaniards, as curiosities, immensely large horns of this description.


3 Humboldt : Neuhispanien, ii. 138.
[My comment (A. Whittall). This quote is correct, Humboldt wrote: "The Mexicans had not yet attempted to domesticate the two species of wild oxen (Bos americanus and B. moschatus) that roam in herds on the plains along the River del Norte. These are the American bison and the muskox.]


It is possible that the stags formerly ranged from New California, and other regions of North America, where they are still found in great numbers, to the interior of Mexico. To a native of China it must have seemed remarkable that the Mexicans should have prepared butter from hind's milk, since such a thing has seldom been done in China, either in ancient or modern times....
It is indeed possible that the Chinese have described an animal similar to the horse with the character Ma, or horse, for changes of this nature are of frequent occurrence.1 In such a manner many names of animals in the Old World have been applied to others of an entirely different nature in the New. The eastern limits of the' Asiatic Continent are also the limits of the native land of the horse, and it appears that it was first taken in the third century of our era from Korea into Japan. But let the error in regard to the American horses have come from what source it will, the unprejudiced, circumspect inquirer will not be etermined on account of it to declare the entire story of Fusang-Mexico an idle tale. It appears to me that this description of the western coast of America is at least as authentic as the discovery of the eastern coast, as narrated in Icelandic sagas.

1It is usual for all ignorant or unscientific people to give to animals for which they have no name that of some other creature with which they are familiar. Thus the gipsies speak of a fox as a weshni jucTcal, or wood-dog ; of an elephant as a loro naJckescro gry, or great-nosed horse ; of a monkey as a ionibaros, and a lion as a horo iomlaros, or big monkey, from their connection in menageries. Professor Neumann was probably ignorant of the fact, to which I allude more fully in another place, that the fossil remains of many horses found in America are of so recent a period, according to Professor Leidy, that they were probably coeval with man. — C. G. L.
"


The oxen are taken up again on p. 153 with an interesting explanation that equates them with bison:


"We may, perhaps, even dispense with supposing that the oxen seen by Hoei-shin were bison, if we admit that domestic cattle may have existed in America, and been exterminated. Thus, in the "Relation de Choses de Yucatan de Diego de Landa," the author tells us that an Indian chief named Cocom showed him one day an ancient book containing the picture of a common European cow, and told him it had been prophesied that when such beasts should come into the country, the worship of the gods would cease — " Cessario el culto de los Dioses, y que se avia cumplido, porque los espanoles truxeron vacas grandes." It is true that this may have been a mere trick of the Indian to flatter the Spaniard.
D'Eichthal has vindicated Deguignes as regards the statement that hinds (biches) were domesticated in Fusang, and that cheese was made from their milk, by citing from the "Popol-Vuh" (Introduction, p. xl.)" Milk was known to the Mexicans, who were accustomed to milk bison-cows and tame hinds, and make cheese." The statement appears to have been taken from Castaneda.
"


My comment: Hind is a mature female deer. The word "biches" used by Deguinges is French for "hind".


Regarding the quote from Popol-Vuh, I disagree; there is no refrence in the Popol-Vuh about cheese-making by the ancient Mayas using deer milk. In fact, the quote mentioned above and cited as "Popol-Vuh, Introduction p. xl" is a circular reference, because going to D'Eichthal's work (see it here, p. 151) we see that the quote originated in the work of M. l’Abbé Brasseur de Bourbourg, in his introduction to the Popol-Vuh, but, where he quotes the Fusang book; the text on p. xl says [in Fusang] "They raise deer like oxen, and make a drink from milk."


The mention of father Diego de Landa (1524-1579) and his Relación de las Cosas de Yucatan (p.14) is correct, but excluded some relevant text. The original says: "Don Juan Cocom... le contó muchas antigúedades y le mostró un libro que fue de su abuelo, hijo de Cocom que mataron en Mayapán, y en él estaba pintado un venado; y que aquel su abuelo le había dicho que cuando en aquella tierra entrasen venados grandes, que así llamaban a las vacas, cesaría el culto de los Dioses; y que se había cumplido porque los españoles trajeron vacas grandes" which in English is: "Juan Cocom... told him many ancient stories and showed him a book that had belonged to his grandfather, the son of Cocom who was killed in Mayapán, and in it was painted a deer; and that his grandfather had told him that when large deer, which is what they called cows, entered that land, the worship of the gods would cease; and that it had come to pass because the Spaniards brought large cows."


So, were they cows or deer (venados)? or did the natives use the word "deer" and applied it to some local bovid, probably American bison?


I have posted several times in the past about American cows and horses (See two examples Native Pre-Hispanic Cattle in Patagonia?, and the survival of native horses in the Americas, so I am not surprised at them being mentioned in Mesoamerica.


It is very likely that Chinese ships crossed the North Pacific Ocean and took advantage of its natural resources (forestry, salmons, seals, Steller sea cows) and visited Alaska, and the west coast of Canada, the U.S., and Mexico.


My next posts will look into Eastern Asia (China and Japan) and their possible pre-Columbian contacts with America.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2026 by Austin Whittall © 

Monday, December 8, 2025

From Guinea (Africa) to America before Columbus


Bartolomé de las Casas in his Historia de las Indias, wrote that Columbus wrote about John II (1455-1495), the King of Portugal, who believed that there was land south of the Cape Verde Islands, furthermore, "King John had a great inclination to send men to explore the Southwest, and canoes had been found leaving the coast of Guinea, sailing west with merchandise". (p. 225)


On p. 244 de las Casas mentions that during Columbus' third voyage in 1498, on August 7, they ment natives who "brought very finely crafted and woven cotton handkerchiefs, with colors and designs like those they bring from Guinea, from the rivers of Sierra Leone, without difference, and he says that they could not communicate with those, because there are more than 800 leagues from here where he is now, to there; below he says that they look like alymayzares." The Spanish word almaizar (also almayzar, almaizal) has a Moorish origin and is applied to fine fabric such as silk, flax, and cotton, or gauze, used to manufacture headdresses, veils, or turbans.


Clearly, the natives wove fine cotton cloth if Columbus compares it with Spanish almayzares.


almaizar
Silk almaizar, c.IX-X century. Source

Columbus had visited the Gulf of Guinea and had stayed at the castle of San Jorge de la Mina in 1481, built by the Portuguese, so he must have seen the Sierra Leone cloth there (Source, p. 485).


The anonymous pilot


An interesting article by Juan José Guerra Pérez-Maffei, Cristóbal Colón y el piloto anónimo (Cristopher Columbus and the anonymous pilot) explores the story that says that "Columbus took in a dying sailor at his home in Porto Santo, in the Madeira archipelago. This sailor had made a long voyage under extreme conditions, and most of the crew had died from an epidemic. This anonymous pilot, before dying, as a gesture of gratitude, revealed his discovery to Christopher Columbus, indicating all the navigational terms he had collected on his long voyage: courses, distances, descriptions, and sketches for traveling to and from the New World. It is not known exactly whether this sailor gave him navigational charts explaining how to reach the Indies or gave him precise instructions on how to get there."


The article suggests that the pilot was a Spaniard, Pedro de Covides, who in 1478, escaping from a Portuguese attack on the coast of Africa, reached America. He met Columbus in 1482-83. It says that the white-skinned people Columbus found on Hispaniola in 1492 were the outcome of intercourse between the sailors of the 1478 ship and the locals (Columbus described the people he met on Hispaniola as follows (Source): "their skins are whiter than the others. They saw two girls whose skins were as white as any that could be seen in Spain" (p. 109) and "They are fairly white, and if they were clothed and protected from the sun and air, they would be almost as fair as people in Spain. " (p. 113).


The "Madeira" story was also reported, with a different date and nationality, back in 1899 by Ellen M. Taylor: "...Perestrello whose third daughter Filippa married the great Christopher Columbus who had settled at Porto Santo shortly after its discovery and earned a living there by drawing maritime charts. Christopher Columbus afterwards came over to Madeira and lived in Funchal. Even at that time vessels of different nationalities called at the island and Columbus's charts were in great demand. Old writers suppose that it was he who first introduced the Madeira group into existing maps. Fructuoso writes that in 1486 a Biscayan vessel arrived at Funchal much battered by storms and the crew utterly worn out and famished. Columbus gave shelter and food to these men but weakened by their sufferings they all died and their pilot as a token of gratitude bequeathed to Columbus all their papers and charts with valuable matter for thought and enterprise in the hoped for discoveries of the Western Ocean..." (Source - see p. 163).


But the tale is even older; de Oviedo in the first volume of his Historia General y Natural de las Indias Chap. II wrote the following version of the story, in 1535:


"Some say that a caravel that was passing from Spain to England loaded with merchandise and provisions, as well as wines and other things that are usually loaded for that island, which it lacks and is in need of, happened to encounter such forceful and adverse times, that it was necessary to sail west for so many days that it explored one or more of the islands of these parts and the Indies; and it came ashore, and saw naked people, in the way that there are here; and that when the winds, which against its will brought it here, had ceased, it took water and firewood to return to its original course. They say more: that the majority of the cargo this ship carried consisted of provisions, food, and wine; and that thus they had enough to sustain themselves on such a long and arduous voyage; and that afterward, the time came for its purpose, and it turned back, and such favorable navigation followed that it returned to Europe and went to Portugal. But since the voyage was so long and arduous, and especially for those who undertook it with such fear and danger, however swift its voyage, it would have taken them four or five months, or perhaps more, to come here and return to where I have said. And during this time almost all the people on the ship died, and only the pilot and three or four, or perhaps a few more, of the sailors left Portugal, and all of them were so ill that they died a few days after arriving.
It is said, along with this, that this pilot was a very close friend of Christopher Columbus, and that he understood something about the skies; and he marked the land he found in the manner described, and in great secrecy informed Columbus of this, and begged him to draw him a chart and mark on it the land he had seen. It is said that Columbus took him into his home, as a friend, and nursed him back to health, because he too was very ill; but that he too died like the others, and that thus Columbus was informed of the land and navigation of these parts, and this secret was kept secret only by him. Some say that this master or pilot was Andalusian; others say he was Portuguese; others Basque; others say that Columbus was then on the island of Madeira, and others say that he was on the Cape Verde Islands, and that the caravel I mentioned landed there, and that he thus learned of this land.
"


Francisco López de Gomara in his work Historia General de las Indias (p. 37), published in 1552, repeats the account:


"The First Discovery of the Indies.
A caravel sailing across our Ocean Sea encountered such a strong and constant easterly wind that it ran aground on a land unknown and unmarked on any map or nautical chart. It took many more days to return; and when it arrived here, it had only the pilot and three or four other sailors, who, being sick from hunger and exhaustion, died shortly afterward in the port. Here is how the Indies were discovered, to the misfortune of the one who first saw them, for he ended his life without enjoying them and without leaving, at least, any memory of his name, his place of origin, or the year he found them. Although it was not his fault, but the malice of others or the envy of what they call fortune. And I am not surprised by ancient histories that recount great deeds from small or obscure beginnings, for we do not know who recently discovered the Indies, which is such a remarkable and new thing. We will at least have the name of that pilot, for all things perish with death. Some say this pilot was Andalusian, trading in the Canary Islands and Madeira when that long and deadly voyage befell him; others say he was Basque, trading in England and France; and still others say he was Portuguese, traveling to or from the Middle East or India, which fits well with the name those new lands took and still bear. There are also those who say he brought the caravel to Portugal, and those who say to Madeira or one of the other Azores islands; however, no one is certain. They all agree, however, that this pilot died at Christopher Columbus's house, in whose possession remained the caravel's registration documents and the account of that entire long voyage, including the marks and latitudes of the newly sighted and discovered lands.
"


We will never know if these stories are true or not, or if they were made up later to later to deny Columbus priority in the discovery of the New World.



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2025 by Austin Whittall © 

Friday, August 22, 2025

A great book about "Pre-Columbian Transoceanic Voyages" America and the Old World


For those interested in an extensive and exahustive analysis of plants, animals, and pathogens that support ancient (or older than 1492 AD) contact between America and the rest of the World, please check out this link to a great book, (online).


Aware of the fact that websites vanish or content changes over time, I saved the link to the Wayback Machine Internet Archive, to preserve the link and the original content it lead to).


This is the book:

John L. Sorenson and Carl L. Johannessen. (2004), Scientific Evidence for Pre-Columbian Transoceanic Voyages. Sino-Platonic Papers, Number 133 April, 2004. Victor H. Mair, Editor



Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia Copyright 2009-2025 by Austin Whittall © 

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Phoenicians and Hebrews in Pre-Columbian Patagonia

 
Tehuelche Rock Art with Semitic symbols and weird snake. From [1]

Researching on Homo erectus and possible entry routes into America from the Old World, I suggested (Out of Africa and into America - H. erectus), transatlantic route in crude rafts. Further reading on rock art and Tehuelche sculptures (looking for H. erectus depictions), led me to some strange stone artifacts found in Patagonia that represent snakes and, symbols. This is very odd, because, the Tehuelche like all native South Americans, did not write (no letters or numbers. No symbols). Mesoamerica is another case and the Mayas could read and write in special symbols.

The snakes interested me, because, there are fossils of giant snakes in Patagonia, that come from precisely the same place that these engraved stones did: Chubut province, Argentina. (Read more on Giant Patagonian snakes).

These Patagonian symbols (see them in the image above, on top of the snake), according to some researchers who studied them, are Semitic, and were engraved by some Hebrew navigators who somehow reached Patagonia.

I was about to dismiss the whole stuff as a fraud when I came across an older publication which mentions these stones. So I filed the information and just left it there. Wondering if it could have any relationship with Patagonian myths and beliefs regarding "monsters".

Then I came across more data regarding Phoenicians in Brazil (yes, they were purportedly taken by the same currents and trade winds that would have pushed H. erectus across from Africa). Phoenicians were good sailors and, in fact sailed around Africa from the Red Sea to the Delta of the Nile. Later expeditions from Carthage (originally a Phoenician Colony) reached Cameroon and maybe even further south. They could have, in theory reached America.

So, once again people from the Western Mediterranean are linked to Southern South America. Could they have influenced the locals? Did any of their myths permeate local culture? Are their genes mixed with the native American's?

I know that none of this has any relationship with cryptozoology (or if it does, it is very tenuous), but I am still intrigued by the strange snakes depicted in the carved stones and who were the people who carved them. The image above shows one of these snakes.

So, I will be writing about this in my next posts. You may find it quite amusing, as I will go beyond the usual "copy paste" found in most blogs and forums, and get to the documents. Some of which are in Spanish or Portuguese, so the English reader will appreciate my translations.

To be continued...

Sources.

[1] Antonio Garcés,(1951). Libro del Cincuentenario de Comodoro Rivadavia, 1901-1951. Aspectos de la Arqueología Patagónica. Chap. 29.


Patagonian Monsters - Cryptozoology, Myths & legends in Patagonia
2011 International Year of Forests
2011 International Year of Forests Copyright 2009-2011 by Austin Whittall © 
Hits since Sept. 2009:
Copyright © 2009-2025 by Austin Victor Whittall.
Todos los derechos reservados por Austin Whittall para esta edición en idioma español y / o inglés. No se permite la reproducción parcial o total, el almacenamiento, el alquiler, la transmisión o la transformación de este libro, en cualquier forma o por cualquier medio, sea electrónico o mecánico, mediante fotocopias, digitalización u otros métodos, sin el permiso previo y escrito del autor, excepto por un periodista, quien puede tomar cortos pasajes para ser usados en un comentario sobre esta obra para ser publicado en una revista o periódico. Su infracción está penada por las leyes 11.723 y 25.446.

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means - electronic, mechanical, photocopy, recording, or any other - except for brief quotations in printed reviews, without prior written permission from the author, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review.

Please read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy before accessing this blog.

Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy

Patagonian Monsters - https://patagoniamonsters.blogspot.com/